Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Bayfield recorded 32 car accidents in La Plata County between 2023 and 2025. 19 resulted in injuries. CrashStory ranks Bayfield’s top wrongful death attorneys by analyzing 67 verified client reviews across 4 firms — scored on rating, review depth, sentiment, and responsiveness. Updated monthly from live data.
Browse the latest crash data and accident reports in and around Bayfield, La Plata County.
Look up your accident report using our free search tool. Find details, other parties involved, and explore your legal options.
Find Your AccidentSumrall Law Office, LLC has accumulated 54 Google reviews with a 4.9-star average, including 44 client reviews that CrashStory analyzed for this ranking. Client reviews most frequently mention personal injury, truck accident, and auto accident cases, indicating breadth across wrongful death matters in Bayfield. 98% of analyzed reviews express positive sentiment, with clients particularly praising communication and case timeline. Trust indicators include 2 peer endorsements from other attorneys.
“Marshall/Ethan were the best criminal law attorneys I have ever worked with. From our first meeting, they explained everything to me in terms I could easily understand and were always very responsi...”
“I drive a semi truck for a living. As such, my driver's license is of the utmost importance to me. I hired Mr. Sumrall to represent me for a citation I was given at the port of entry.”
“I had an excellent experience with Mr. Sumrall. He is highly professional, knowledgeable, and generally cared about my case.”
Sumrall Law Office, LLC’s Bayfield office serves La Plata County, where 32 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2025. 19 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Harlan Hillier DiGiacco LLP has accumulated 10 Google reviews with a 4.6-star average, including 10 client reviews that CrashStory analyzed for this ranking. Client reviews most frequently mention personal injury, and auto accident cases, indicating breadth across wrongful death matters in Bayfield. 100% of analyzed reviews express positive sentiment overall. Trust indicators include 3 peer endorsements from other attorneys.
“I am a semi-retired California attorney now residing in Durango. I needed an attorney for the litigation of a commercial property I own in southern California.”
“I really didn't know what to do about any legal issues with my car accident. Mr. Harlan patently answered all my questions regarding the accident and procedures.”
“Jordon and Taylor were so extremely helpful in my post-car accident experience. It’s scary and intimidating not knowing how to handle something as major as being in an accident where you not only e...”
Harlan Hillier DiGiacco LLP’s Bayfield office serves La Plata County, where 32 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2025. 19 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Carroll Kirk B Attorney at Law has accumulated 1 Google reviews with a 5.0-star average, including 1 client reviews that CrashStory analyzed for this ranking. 100% of analyzed reviews express positive sentiment overall.
“Kirk did a great job! My ordeal started 3 years ago with another lawyer. It was 3 years of throwing every dollar I had made/was making at my previous lawyer for doing absolutely nothing and had enough.”
Carroll Kirk B Attorney at Law’s Bayfield office serves La Plata County, where 32 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2025. 19 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
The Law Firm of Marla C. Underell has accumulated 2 Google reviews with a 3.0-star average, including 1 client reviews that CrashStory analyzed for this ranking. 100% of analyzed reviews express positive sentiment overall.
The Law Firm of Marla C. Underell’s Bayfield office serves La Plata County, where 32 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2025. 19 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Side-by-side comparison using CrashStory’s proprietary review analysis. Data sourced from 67 total client reviews.
| Firm | Rating | Reviews | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. Sumrall Law Office, LLC | 4.9 | 54 | Top-rated by clients |
| #2. Harlan Hillier DiGiacco LLP | 4.6 | 10 | Highest overall score |
| #3. Carroll Kirk B Attorney at Law | 5.0 | 1 | Top-rated by clients |
| #4. The Law Firm of Marla C. Underell | 3.0 | 2 | Real Estate specialist |
CrashStory’s rankings are data-driven, not pay-to-play. We analyze every Google review for each firm using natural language processing across 12 consumer-relevant dimensions. Here’s what goes into the score:
Google star rating weighted by the total number of reviews. A 4.9 with 500 reviews signals more consistency than a 5.0 with 12.
We count text reviews separately from star-only reviews. Detailed narratives provide more signal about actual client experience than a quick 5-star tap.
Each text review is analyzed for positive, negative, or mixed sentiment across dimensions like communication, fee transparency, and personal attention.
How many reviews a firm receives per month indicates how actively they’re serving clients. A firm gaining 40 reviews/month is more active than one with 2,000 reviews from years ago.
We track whether firms respond to reviews, and whether those responses are personalized, semi-personalized, or boilerplate. Personalized responses signal client care.
Peer endorsements from other attorneys, Google Local Guide reviews, and cross-firm comparison shoppers add independent credibility to a firm’s review profile.
Rankings provide a starting point, but the best lawyer for your case depends on your specific circumstances. Here’s how to use CrashStory’s data to make your decision:
Bayfield sits in La Plata County, one of Colorado’s highest-traffic areas. In the CrashStory database, Bayfield has 32 recorded crashes from 2023 through 2025. 19 of those involved injuries0. The most common crash type is not applicable collisions.
Bayfield’s most dangerous corridors for car accidents include US Highway 160, Bayfield Parkway. If your accident occurred on or near these corridors, a local attorney familiar with La Plata County’s specific accident patterns can be especially valuable.