Mr. Bottalico was candid and straightforward about my matter which enabled me to have a clear understanding and formulate the appropriate strategy for resolving the issues successfully.
CrashStory
!
Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Request a free case review from Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law in Garden City, New York.
Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law
Garden City Personal Injury Lawyer — 53 Client Reviews Analyzed
5.0(53 reviews)Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law is a Personal Injury law firm in Garden City, NY, located at 1225 Franklin Ave RM 325 and reachable at +1516-543-1329. Clients have rated the firm 5.0 out of 5 across 53 public Google reviews, 10 of which include written feedback. The most recent written review is from andre strishak on May 8, 2026 (90 days ago).
Owner engagement: Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law replies on 85% of visible Google reviews — one of the 12 client-experience dimensions CrashStory's review intelligence scores. Use this as a proxy for how responsive the firm is likely to be with you.
What reviewers consistently praise: care for the whole situation, help during a stressful moment, and clear next steps. These themes surfaced across dozens of reviews when CrashStory analyzed sentiment and case-experience dimensions on this firm's Google reviews. Compare these against any other firm you're considering — most attorneys have only two or three themes reviewers consistently return to.
How we compiled this: CrashStory aggregates public Google reviews, Colorado crash records from CDOT and local agencies, and firm-provided profile data. We do not endorse any firm. Review intelligence scores are derived from automated sentiment and theme analysis of public reviews — treat them as one signal among many, not a verdict.
53 reviews
Years Experience
Practice Areas
Office Location
Consultation
Each button opens a new tab with a ready-made prompt that references this CrashStory page and the key facts already shown here.
Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law is a personal injury law firm serving clients in Garden City, New York, located at 1225 Franklin Ave RM 325 11530.
Review evidence: Clients have left 53 public Google reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5, 10 of which include written feedback. CrashStory scores 12 client-experience dimensions across this review corpus — compare side-by-side with other Garden City, New York firms before you decide.
Quick signals: the Google Business profile for this firm is verified; 3 photos are public on Google; contact the firm to ask about consultation fees.
Contact Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law at (516) 543-1329 or visit bottalicolaw.com for a free case review.
53 public reviews and 20 written reviews.
Most recent written review from andre strishak: Feb 6, 2026 (181 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Replies on 100% of recent reviews
The firm responds to reviews; read a few replies below to judge how personal they are.
Most recent written review from andre strishak: Feb 6, 2026 (181 days ago)
CrashStory does not yet have enough structured review evidence on this firm to call out consistent strengths with confidence.
The newest written review in this dataset is from Feb 6, 2026 (181 days ago). Compare that recency with the other firms you are considering.
Mr. Bottalico was candid and straightforward about my matter which enabled me to have a clear understanding and formulate the appropriate strategy for resolving the issues successfully.
Great attorney! Caring and very knowledgeable!
Great experience, knowledgeable and professional. Highly recommend!
1225 Franklin Ave RM 325, Garden City, NY 11530
Recent crash data for the area around Arnold M. Bottalico, Attorney At Law loads when this section comes into view.
Recent written Google reviews from the last 30 days appear first. Older written reviews stay available through pagination and filtering.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from andre strishak: Feb 6, 2026 (181 days ago)
Written Reviews
20
Average Rating
5.00
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
20
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 20 of 20 written reviews.
1 star
0
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
20
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr. Bottalico was candid and straightforward about my matter which enabled me to have a clear understanding and formulate the appropriate strategy for resolving the issues successfully.
Owner response
Thank you Andre
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Great attorney! Caring and very knowledgeable!
Owner response
Thank you Randall for your kind review!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Great experience, knowledgeable and professional. Highly recommend!
Owner response
Thank you Anthony
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Arnold Bottalico is genuinely one of the best attorneys out there. Not only did he do an excellent legal analysis of the case, but patiently explained the details to us. I whole heartedly recommend him. We had reached out to him for legal advice over an ongoing case and honestly we wish we had gone to him sooner. Thank you Mr Bottalico!
Owner response
Thank you Joann for your kind words, and I wish you success!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I called Arnold with few questions about some legal issues I was dealing with & even though it wasn't his expertise, he still took the time to listen & provide very useful feedback. He even took my call again to help guide me when I was unable to find any other lawyer & offered very reliable & thoughtful advice. I definitely recommend his services to anyone looking for a lawyer!!
Owner response
Thank you Mirza for your kind words, and I wish you well!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
They answered every question I had. He took the time to give his honest opinion and helped me greatly! I am so appreciative and would give more than 5 starts if possible.
Owner response
Thank you Elizabeth for your kind words!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I give Mr. Bottalico the highest rating I can give....5 Stars! I only wish I could give 10 Stars!! Mr. Bottalico handled my Dad's reverse mortgage foreclosure. Mr. Bottalico was patient with us and explained everything. His rates are reasonable. I would recommend him in a New York Minute! Thank you so very much Mr. B.
Owner response
Thank you Georgette for your kind words!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Building I live in is a foreclosure process right now in Brooklyn. I have been receiving court papers with all the legal language which is not easy for me to fully understand. I searched for lawyers and found Mr. Botallico just this morning and He was extremely helpful. Mr Botallico spent a significant amount of time on the phone to explain me my rights and best way forward. I am extremely thankful for his help and plus it was basically a free consultation which I am sure very rare these days. Thank you
Owner response
Thank you for your kind words Emil and best regards!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr Bottalico is a true professional, a reminder that integrity, knowledge and honesty is not just learned, but innate. Had we been in contact sooner, it would have undoubtedly saved my elderly parent years of litigation and life savings after hiring the wrong attorneys. Highly recommended.
Owner response
I thank you for your kind review and wish you both the best.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr Bottalico.. He’s a very nice guy and very professional he take his time to explain things to you if you don’t understand anything , he’ll be gladly to answer all the questions you have and explain things to you I would recommend Mr. Bottalico to anyone else he is the best ...
Owner response
Thank you for your kind words Marielyn!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Very helpful. Super informative. Expert in law! Would highly recommend and use again
Owner response
Thank you Maura!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Very professional, caring, goes above and beyond everytime. Highly recommend
Owner response
Thank you Bridgette for your kind words!
Other personal injury lawyers near this office
Browse all personal injury lawyers serving Garden City, New York.
View All Garden City LawyersCompare nearby firms, browse city lawyer directories, and read case-type guides before you decide who to contact.
Showing fallback links while lawyer performance data refreshes.
0 this week, 0 this month
Last review 176d ago
stable