These guys are great the team was amazing and very great at communication! They handled my motorcycle case and took very good care of me!
CrashStory
!
Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Request a free case review from The Nicotra Law Firm in Buffalo, New York.
The Nicotra Law Firm
Buffalo Personal Injury Lawyer — 262 Client Reviews Analyzed
5.0(262 reviews)The Nicotra Law Firm is a Personal Injury law firm in Buffalo, NY, located at 487 Main St #500 and reachable at +1716-333-3000. Clients have rated the firm 5.0 out of 5 across 262 public Google reviews, 10 of which include written feedback. The most recent written review is from AAMP SOLUTIONS on May 8, 2026 (86 days ago).
Owner engagement: The Nicotra Law Firm replies on 15% of visible Google reviews, and roughly 82% of those replies are at least somewhat personalized rather than fully templated — one of the 12 client-experience dimensions CrashStory's review intelligence scores. Use this as a proxy for how responsive the firm is likely to be with you.
What reviewers consistently praise: care for the whole situation, communication and updates, and clear next steps. These themes surfaced across dozens of reviews when CrashStory analyzed sentiment and case-experience dimensions on this firm's Google reviews. Compare these against any other firm you're considering — most attorneys have only two or three themes reviewers consistently return to.
How we compiled this: CrashStory aggregates public Google reviews, Colorado crash records from CDOT and local agencies, and firm-provided profile data. We do not endorse any firm. Review intelligence scores are derived from automated sentiment and theme analysis of public reviews — treat them as one signal among many, not a verdict.
262 reviews
Years Experience
Practice Areas
Office Location
Consultation
Each button opens a new tab with a ready-made prompt that references this CrashStory page and the key facts already shown here.
The Nicotra Law Firm is a personal injury law firm serving clients in Buffalo, New York, located at 487 Main St #500 14203.
Review evidence: Clients have left 262 public Google reviews averaging 5.0 out of 5, 10 of which include written feedback. CrashStory scores 12 client-experience dimensions across this review corpus — compare side-by-side with other Buffalo, New York firms before you decide.
Quick signals: the Google Business profile for this firm is verified; 41 photos are public on Google; contact the firm to ask about consultation fees.
Contact The Nicotra Law Firm at (716) 333-3000 or visit 866nicotra.com for a free case review.
262 public reviews and 20 written reviews.
Most recent written review from AAMP SOLUTIONS: Mar 13, 2026 (142 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Replies on 55% of recent reviews
The firm responds to reviews; read a few replies below to judge how personal they are.
Most recent written review from AAMP SOLUTIONS: Mar 13, 2026 (142 days ago)
CrashStory does not yet have enough structured review evidence on this firm to call out consistent strengths with confidence.
The newest written review in this dataset is from Mar 13, 2026 (142 days ago). Compare that recency with the other firms you are considering.
These guys are great the team was amazing and very great at communication! They handled my motorcycle case and took very good care of me!
The staff is all top notch. Very happy with everything
Had a great experience, everything was done remotely,staff was great
487 Main St #500, Buffalo, NY 14203
Recent crash data for the area around The Nicotra Law Firm loads when this section comes into view.
Recent written Google reviews from the last 30 days appear first. Older written reviews stay available through pagination and filtering.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from AAMP SOLUTIONS: Mar 13, 2026 (142 days ago)
Written Reviews
20
Average Rating
4.85
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
20
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 20 of 20 written reviews.
1 star
0
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
3
5 star
17
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
These guys are great the team was amazing and very great at communication! They handled my motorcycle case and took very good care of me!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
The staff is all top notch. Very happy with everything
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Had a great experience, everything was done remotely,staff was great
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Rick and his team really did a good job on my case
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Very Professional
Owner response
Thanks Rick ! We really appreciate the feedback and review. Don’t forget, we’re always here for any questions or assistance needed with the claim in the future.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Working with Nicotra law firm was a very smooth and easy going process, they team there were very helpful and supportive I definitely recommend!!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Very, very, professional, kind, and they answer any questions you have.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Great work with them. They helped us with everything
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Would highly recommend this firm! I was very impressed with how my case was handle all the way through. Any questions I had were always answered, communication was great. I felt like I had someone who listened to what I wanted and how I felt. I would call them again if I ever needed too!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
You guys worked hard and fast and you kept me in form of all the steps you where taking
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Recently I was a victim of a dog attack where I was personally mauled by someone's unleashed dog. Although I'm still pending litigation, I am extremely happy with the care and service Nicotra Law has provided thus far. They accepted my case without hesitation and provided more emotional support than I would've thought possible. God forbid something happens to me again, I wouldn't think twice about calling them.
Owner response
Thanks Alex ! We really appreciate the feedback and review. Don’t forget, we’re always here for any questions or assistance needed with the claim in the future.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Nicotra Law Firm was an absolute lifeline for our family. From the very beginning, they were supportive, communicative, and incredibly compassionate during what was one of the scariest times we’ve experienced. Every question was answered promptly, and we never felt alone or unsure about what was happening. Their steady presence, kindness, and professionalism made an overwhelming situation feel manageable. I truly believe their guidance and care are a big part of why we were able to get through such a difficult period. I would highly recommend Nicotra Law Firm to anyone facing a stressful situation and looking for a legal team that truly cares.
Owner response
Thanks for sharing your feedback - we treat clients like family and fight to the end for their best possible outcome, while handling every aspect of the claims process along the way.
2 other offices for this firm
Other personal injury lawyers near this office
Browse all personal injury lawyers serving Buffalo, New York.
View All Buffalo LawyersCompare nearby firms, browse city lawyer directories, and read case-type guides before you decide who to contact.
0 this week, 0 this month
Last review 141d ago
declining