Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
No fee unless you win. Talk to a top-rated attorney about your accident in minutes — compare the firms below, then get matched.
Firms are listed most-reviewed first — by the number of client reviews they have on Google — with equal counts broken alphabetically. Position cannot be bought. Paid advertisements appear only in the separate block labelled “Sponsored” below. What we analyse and show about each firm does not change the order:
Carbondale recorded 245 car accidents in Garfield County between 2023 and 2026. 43 resulted in injuries. CrashStory lists Carbondale’s bicycle accident attorneys most-reviewed first, and shows what 61 client reviews across 3 firmsactually say. Position cannot be bought.
Browse the latest crash data and accident reports in and around Carbondale, Garfield County.
Look up your accident report using our free search tool. Find details, other parties involved, and explore your legal options.
Find Your AccidentDonald J. Kaufman, Attorney at Law, LLC has accumulated 46 Google reviews with a 4.7-star average, including 33 client reviews that CrashStory analyzed for this ranking. 94% of analyzed reviews express positive sentiment, with clients particularly praising case timeline and personal attention. Trust indicators include 1 peer endorsement from other attorneys, 6 reviewers who also reviewed other firms (comparison shoppers).
Reported by reviewers on Google, not by CrashStory, and not verified by us. These are descriptions of the reviews in our sample — their rating, case type and date — not the reviews themselves; each firm's reviews are on its Google listing. Ordered by how much case detail the review contains, filtered to reviews mentioning this case type.
Donald J. Kaufman, Attorney at Law, LLC’s Carbondale office serves Garfield County, where 245 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2026. 43 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Mark S Rubinstein P C Carbondale has 11 Google reviews with a 4.6-star average. CrashStory analyzed 10 text reviews for this Carbondale bicycle accident ranking. Trust signals include a 82% response rate to reviews.
Mark S. Rubinstein, P.C.’s Carbondale office serves Garfield County, where 245 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2026. 43 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Law Office Of William G Argeros Carbondale has 4 Google reviews with a 5.0-star average. CrashStory analyzed 4 text reviews for this Carbondale bicycle accident ranking. Clients most frequently review this firm for personal injury, auto accident, and bicycle matters. Trust signals include 1 peer endorsements from other attorneys.
Law Office of William G. Argeros’s Carbondale office serves Garfield County, where 245 crashes were recorded between 2023 and 2026. 43 involved injuries. The most common type: not applicable collisions.
Side-by-side comparison using CrashStory’s proprietary review analysis. Data sourced from 61 total client reviews.
| Firm | Rating | Reviews | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1. Donald J. Kaufman, Attorney at Law, LLC | 4.7 | 46 | Highest overall score |
| #2. Mark S. Rubinstein, P.C. | 4.6 | 11 | Strong client satisfaction |
| #3. Law Office of William G. Argeros | 5.0 | 4 | Top-rated by clients |
No Carbondale firm has surfaced bicycle accident review depth yet. These statewide bicycle accident specialists frequently accept cases from Garfield County.
Denver — outside Carbondale
Fort Collins — outside Carbondale
Fort Collins — outside Carbondale
Denver — outside Carbondale
Lafayette — outside Carbondale
Editor’s note
None of the Carbondale firms in CrashStory's review dataset have client reviews that specifically describe bicycle accident cases yet, so this page pairs Carbondale's general injury firms with statewide bicycle accident specialists. The 5 statewide specialists listed in the regional section have 28 client reviews describing bicycle accident cases between them, led by Bike Law Weiss Law Llc Denver. Colorado injury firms routinely take Garfield County cases regardless of office location, and nearly all offer free consultations.
Firms are listed in order of how many client reviews they have on Google, most first — the count is printed beside each firm. Firms with the same count are listed alphabetically by their CrashStory profile address. Position cannot be bought: no payment, subscription, or advertising spend changes this order, and paid advertisements appear only in the separate block labelled “Sponsored”. The review analysis below is what we show you about each firm; it does not change the order:
Google star rating weighted by the total number of reviews. A 4.9 with 500 reviews signals more consistency than a 5.0 with 12.
We count text reviews separately from star-only reviews. Detailed narratives provide more signal about actual client experience than a quick 5-star tap.
Each text review is analyzed for positive, negative, or mixed sentiment across dimensions like communication, fee transparency, and personal attention.
How many reviews a firm receives per month indicates how actively they’re serving clients. A firm gaining 40 reviews/month is more active than one with 2,000 reviews from years ago.
We track whether firms respond to reviews, and whether those responses are personalized, semi-personalized, or boilerplate. Personalized responses signal client care.
Peer endorsements from other attorneys, Google Local Guide reviews, and cross-firm comparison shoppers add independent credibility to a firm’s review profile.
Rankings provide a starting point, but the best lawyer for your case depends on your specific circumstances. Here’s how to use CrashStory’s data to make your decision:
Carbondale sits in Garfield County, one of Colorado’s highest-traffic areas. In the CrashStory database, Carbondale has 245 recorded crashes from 2023 through 2026. 43 of those involved injuries0. The most common crash type is not applicable collisions.
Carbondale’s most dangerous corridors for car accidents include State Highway 133, HWY 133, Main Street, among others. If your accident occurred on or near these corridors, a local attorney familiar with Garfield County’s specific accident patterns can be especially valuable.
Free Consultation — No Fee Unless You Win
This review describes a case outcome.
Reported by reviewers on Google, not by CrashStory, and not verified by us. These are descriptions of the reviews in our sample — their rating, case type and date — not the reviews themselves; each firm's reviews are on its Google listing. Ordered by how much case detail the review contains, filtered to reviews mentioning this case type.
This review mentions a settlement in the 500k+ range.
This review describes a case outcome, mentions a settlement in the 100k-500k range.