Made the mistake of hiring this guy and finding him completely ineffectual. Tried to get a different attorney and they all said it's your own fault for going with the low bid guy. He was worse than useless.
Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Request a free case review from Cimasi Law Office in Amherst, New York.
Cimasi Law Office
Amherst Personal Injury Lawyer — 50 Client Reviews Analyzed
4.8(50 reviews)Cimasi Law Office is a Personal Injury law firm in Amherst, NY, located at 66 Park Cir and reachable at +1716-267-6430. Clients have rated the firm 4.8 out of 5 across 50 public Google reviews, 10 of which include written feedback. The most recent written review is from Jump Street on May 8, 2026 (130 days ago).
Owner engagement: Cimasi Law Office replies on 80% of visible Google reviews, and roughly 8% of those replies are at least somewhat personalized rather than fully templated — one of the 12 client-experience dimensions CrashStory's review intelligence scores. Use this as a proxy for how responsive the firm is likely to be with you.
What reviewers consistently praise: communication and updates, care for the whole situation, and help during a stressful moment. These themes surfaced across dozens of reviews when CrashStory analyzed sentiment and case-experience dimensions on this firm's Google reviews. Compare these against any other firm you're considering — most attorneys have only two or three themes reviewers consistently return to.
Named attorneys at this firm: Cimasi Law is the attorney most frequently named by clients in reviews of Cimasi Law Office.
How we compiled this: CrashStory combines public review evidence with directory and firm-provided profile data. We do not endorse any firm. Review intelligence scores are derived from automated sentiment and theme analysis of public reviews — treat them as one signal among many, not a verdict.
50 reviews
Years Experience
Practice Areas
Office Location
Consultation
Each button opens a new tab with a ready-made prompt that references this CrashStory page and the key facts already shown here.
Cimasi Law Office is a personal injury law firm serving clients in Amherst, New York, located at 66 Park Cir 14226.
Review evidence: Clients have left 50 public Google reviews averaging 4.8 out of 5, 10 of which include written feedback. CrashStory scores 12 client-experience dimensions across this review corpus — compare side-by-side with other Amherst, New York firms before you decide.
Quick signals: attorneys named most often in reviews are Cimasi Law; the Google Business profile for this firm is verified; 84 photos are public on Google; contact the firm to ask about consultation fees.
Contact Cimasi Law Office at (716) 267-6430 or visit cimasilaw.com for a free case review.
50 public reviews and 20 written reviews.
Most recent written review from Jump Street: Jan 17, 2026 (241 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Replies on 100% of recent reviews
The firm responds to reviews; read a few replies below to judge how personal they are.
Most recent written review from Jump Street: Jan 17, 2026 (241 days ago)
CrashStory does not yet have enough structured review evidence on this firm to call out consistent strengths with confidence.
The newest written review in this dataset is from Jan 17, 2026 (241 days ago). Compare that recency with the other firms you are considering.
Made the mistake of hiring this guy and finding him completely ineffectual. Tried to get a different attorney and they all said it's your own fault for going with the low bid guy. He was worse than useless.
The guy is good. He told me not to worry, I worried. He's down to earth, not the easiest to get ahold of, but he definitely delivers. I had a criminal case, he took care of it for me and made sure I was safe. He has follow thru and is someone who has earned their trust with me. Thank you Sir!
300 miles away, I was concerned of not knowing anything about him. He returned my calls promptly, addressed my concerns. Thank you
66 Park Cir, Amherst, NY 14226
Recent crash data for the area around Cimasi Law Office loads when this section comes into view.
Recent written Google reviews from the last 30 days appear first. Older written reviews stay available through pagination and filtering.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from Jump Street: Jan 17, 2026 (241 days ago)
Written Reviews
20
Average Rating
4.55
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
20
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 20 of 20 written reviews.
1 star
2
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
1
5 star
17
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Made the mistake of hiring this guy and finding him completely ineffectual. Tried to get a different attorney and they all said it's your own fault for going with the low bid guy. He was worse than useless.
Owner response
Dear Writer,<br><br>Though I cannot know who this is or what the issue might have been, feel free to reach out by text or phone directly to discuss: 716-560-1171. I am always willing to chat on any issue with an identified client in a solutions-oriented fashion.<br><br>Best wishes,<br>Michael Charles Cimasi, Esq.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
The guy is good. He told me not to worry, I worried. He's down to earth, not the easiest to get ahold of, but he definitely delivers. I had a criminal case, he took care of it for me and made sure I was safe. He has follow thru and is someone who has earned their trust with me. Thank you Sir!
Owner response
Thank you, Eric. I hope all is well with you.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
300 miles away, I was concerned of not knowing anything about him. He returned my calls promptly, addressed my concerns. Thank you
Owner response
Thank you, Rani!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr. Cimasi is an absolute pleasure to work with and I highly recommend him for all your law needs.
Owner response
Thank you, Camryn!<br><br>-Mike Cimasi, Esq.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr. Cimasi is the real deal. Highly recommend 👌
Owner response
Thank you, James!<br><br>-Mike Cimasi, Esq.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
To start,I would have given no stars had that been an option. I was assigned Mr. Cimasi thru court. Let me tell you about my experience with him. For starters he visited me once while locked up in erie county correctional facility, and at that time lied to me about having me out within days. He lied because he had guessed at an outcome that was in no way even possible. After not showing up and or adjournment of court of his doing on the days of court. He tried to convince me I was wrong at what the judge had made a commitment too and then proceeded to tell my family three completely different scenarios of my conditional release. None of which were true. He then failed to file paperwork to have me released for an additional 2.5 weeks as well as blocking my calls,my spouses as well as a jail coordinator. I am out ,but this was my to my own calling the courts FROM JAIL to see why I was not being released. He has made my life a nightmare for four months when I was to be freed back inMay. . Steer clear. If you really want to find out yourself ask any inmate sorry enough to have had him take their case. I am filling against him to the bar association as well as the public defenders office. Thank God I worked the law library and was able to figure out on my own how to get it figured out. Criminal lawyer is not what he is. Beware.
Owner response
I provide equal and competent services to all my clients, whether retained or appointed, and am always happy to be of service. I often interface with people at very low points in their lives, and realize this can generate misdirected anger. As I take my ethical obligations quite seriously, I never breach my clients privilege by posting their private information or identifiable case facts online - even when it would be in defense of false allegations. It is one demonstrable downside of these Google posting reviews...there is no mechanism to weed out simply false statements. Past that, I certainly wish you and your family all the best for everything going forward.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr. Cimasi was very knowledgeable and professional. He returned my initial call almost instantly, and he advised me how to proceed with the ticket I had received. His fee was reasonable and well worth it. The results were exactly what he described in the initial phone call - a testament to his knowledge and experience. I highly recommend Cimasi Law.
Owner response
Thank you, Tyler!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
The best lawyer in Buffalo. He works fast and is always there to answer your calls. He is there to defend and win.
Owner response
Thank you, Mary!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Excellentvresponse and service all around.
Owner response
Thank you, Peter!<br>-Michael Charles Cimasi, Esq.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I got into an accident and was issued a ticket and a charge resulting to a damage of property. After a few google research, I reached out to Cimasi Law and their response was quick and professional. They represented me in court and the charge was reduced and resolved. I didn't even have to show up in court. I live in Canada so this was a huge relief. Thanks to Micheal Cimasi and his amazing team for helping me resolve this matter. I will recommend this Law office in a heart beat!.
Owner response
Thank you, Henry!<br>-Michael Charles Cimasi, Esq.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I retained the services of Mr. Cimasi for my teenager who was ticketed in Amherst while driving to Ontario. The outcome of his representation was as he had explained but what impressed me most was his responsiveness. Send text/question and within a short time I would get a response back. AWESOME experience!!
Owner response
Thank you, Rishi!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Mr. Cimasi knows what he's doing. Thanks
Owner response
Dear Mr. Ketch,<br><br>Thank you, and best wishes!<br><br>Sincerely,<br>Michael Charles Cimasi, Esq.
Other personal injury lawyers near this office
Browse all personal injury lawyers serving Amherst, New York.
View All Amherst LawyersCompare nearby firms, browse city lawyer directories, and read case-type guides before you decide who to contact.
0 this week, 0 this month
Last review 204d ago
stable