CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
Law Offices Of John R Mathias P A St Petersburg Fl review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Law Offices Of John R Mathias P A St Petersburg Fl so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.9
Total Reviews
28
PI Reviews
28
Text Reviews
28
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Law Offices Of John R Mathias P A St Petersburg Fl.
What to check before you hire Law Offices Of John R Mathias P A St Petersburg Fl
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.9
33 public reviews and 28 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from Denetria Williams: Aug 29, 2025 (343 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 48% of reviews
Most replies are brief or templated, so review text matters more than response style when comparing firms.
Law Offices Of John R Mathias P A St Petersburg Fl client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All28 reviews
4.9
Most recent written review from Denetria Williams: Aug 29, 2025 (343 days ago)
Written Reviews
28
Average Rating
4.89
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
28
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 28 of 28 written reviews.
1 star
0
2 star
1
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
27
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
I highly recommend John if you are in search of an attorney. I felt overwhelmed by the whole process and was unsure of what to do next. Thankfully, John stepped in and took care of everything. He helped me through the legal process with compassion and professionalism, always keeping me informed and fighting hard on my behalf. I'm truly grateful for his help and would not hesitate to recommend him to friends or family in a similar situation.
Owner response
Thanks M.O. it really means a lot to me. I enjoy helping good people like yourself.
The Law Offices of John R. Mathias, I highly recommend!!!
John & his team have been an asset to my family for well over the past 13 years. He's detail oriented, quick to respond & not to mention, I didn't have to wait 2 years to get compensated! Several years back, I had 2 incidents happen, beyond my control, John & his team handled both cases for me, I trust this firm whole heartedly, so if you're looking for a firm you can trust, look no further, they will work for you & you will win‼️
Owner response
Thanks, Tricina. It's always a pleasure to help you and your family any way I can.
10 stars – Highly Recommended
I hired Attorney Mathias after having the misfortune of being involved in three car wrecks caused by negligent drivers, and I couldn’t be more grateful and satisfied with the guidance and representation I received. Attorney Mathias is not only an experienced personal injury attorney with over 30 years of experience but also a Certified Civil Trial Specialist for over 20 years. This makes him an expert in not only settling but also taking cases to trial. From the very first consultation, he impressed me with his knowledge of personal injury law, auto and health insurance matters, and took the time to explain the entire legal process in great detail every step of the way.
Throughout the entire 5 year process, he kept me informed, counseled me every step and was very attentive and always quick to personally answer any questions I had. As a Certified Civil Trial Attorney, he brought a level of courtroom readiness that most lawyers simply don’t have. Even though my case settled before trial, I know the other side took us seriously because of his credentials and reputation. He handled all of the negotiations with the insurance companies, medical providers, opposing attorneys and fought to make sure I received the compensation I deserved to cover my medical bills, lost wages and more.
I never felt like “just another case”. He truly cared. He is a good man. If you are looking for an experienced, professional, confident attorney with integrity, I wholeheartedly recommend Attorney Mathias and his staff.
Owner response
Thank you, Joanna, for the excellent review. It was a pleasure to represent you. We worked through some challenges, and I'm glad we were able to achieve a great result.
I have used John twice with great results both times. He and his staff are very cordial and professional and make you feel comfortable and relaxed. When I had questions they were quick to get back to me with the answers. I will not hesitate to recommend Mr Mathias to anyone looking for and attorney.
My experience with John was exceptional! From the moment of contact through the process of assisting me in my case. He was very thorough in explaining what my rights were in my accident and I felt very comfortable until settlement. He took the worry away while I was recovering. I will refer him to anyone who needs a P.A attorney from now on. Thanks John!
My experience with Law Offices of John R. Mathias has always been a wonderful experience. I was recommend to him by my mom and have been with them ever since. Very nice and professional. I will highly recommend him to my family and friends. Get in a car accident call “John R. Mathias”.
John and Baylie are really professional, I'm glad to have them as my attorneys. My case was a unique one but I was really surprised that they were able to settled it really quickly. If you're looking for a great lawyer, they are the best one for you
My experience with the Law Offices of John R. Mathias, P.A. was outstanding. The emphasis on great customer service was evident from the start, with a responsive and attentive team dedicated to addressing my concerns promptly. The attorneys’ depth of knowledge was impressive, providing clear explanations of legal complexities and ensuring I felt well-informed throughout the process. Professionalism was a constant, reflected in their ethical conduct and commitment to my best interests. Law Offices of John R. Mathias, P.A. personalized approach created a sense of trust and collaboration, making the legal journey smoother. I highly recommend their services to anyone seeking not only knowledgeable and professional legal representation but also a client-centric experience that exceeds expectations.
My attorney client relationship with John R. Mathias began over 25 years ago. Yes, that long ago! From our initial meeting, he's always been a personable and down to Earth person. He doesn't need to put on any frills, bells, whistles...none of the fake stuff. He's upfront and no empty promises. He's handled all of my cases and I have referred several friends to him. From the initial acceptance of the case, John keeps you informed of everything. You don't have to call and try to find out anything or leave countless messages. If he isn't available he gets back to you or his staff will. Now we talk about our children and family, not just the case. When I refer others to him, I say " Let me give you my friend John's number." I really can't say enough about Attorney John R. Mathias🙂
I highly recommend John if you are in search of an attorney. I felt overwhelmed by the whole process and was unsure of what to do next. Thankfully, John stepped in and took care of everything. He helped me through the legal process with compassion and professionalism, always keeping me informed and fighting hard on my behalf. I'm truly grateful for his help and would not hesitate to recommend him to friends or family in a similar situation.
The Law Offices of John R. Mathias, I highly recommend!!!
John & his team have been an asset to my family for well over the past 13 years. He's detail oriented, quick to respond & not to mention, I didn't have to wait 2 years to get compensated! Several years back, I had 2 incidents happen, beyond my control, John & his team handled both cases for me, I trust this firm whole heartedly, so if you're looking for a firm you can trust, look no further, they will work for you & you will win‼️