CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
Lucarelli Castaldi LLP Staten Island Ny review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Lucarelli Castaldi LLP Staten Island Ny so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
5.0
Total Reviews
23
PI Reviews
23
Text Reviews
23
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Lucarelli Castaldi LLP Staten Island Ny.
What to check before you hire Lucarelli Castaldi LLP Staten Island Ny
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
5.0
26 public reviews and 23 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from Aidan Schoff: Feb 16, 2026 (213 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 46% of reviews
75% of the visible replies look at least somewhat personalized instead of fully templated.
Lucarelli Castaldi LLP Staten Island Ny client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All23 reviews
5.0
Most recent written review from Aidan Schoff: Feb 16, 2026 (213 days ago)
Written Reviews
23
Average Rating
5.00
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
23
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 23 of 23 written reviews.
1 star
0
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
23
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Found myself with a badly broken wrist after being doored on my roadbike in Brooklyn. A biker co-worker recommended me day of and now I'm recommending you.
ANY NYC BIKER who is in need of legal assistance should call Lucarelli & Castaldi.
They walked me through the process on the day of the accident and throughout the rest of the case. Always willing to hop of the phone and able to follow through.
Owner response
Thank you so much for your kind words and recommendation. We’re truly sorry to hear about your accident, but we’re grateful you trusted us to handle your case and guide you through the process. Our team is committed to standing up for NYC cyclists and making sure they get the care and compensation they deserve.<br><br>Wishing you a full and speedy recovery — and safe rides ahead!
Tom resolved my case quickly and to my advantage! His team was easy to work with and I'm very happy with the outcome. Would absolutely work with him again.
In Feb 2024, I was door'd while biking home from the gym. I had a puncture wound in my neck and was extremely lucky that I didn't die. I didn't know what to do as I've never been in this kind of situation before. I found Tom and his firm after a bit of research and they have been a huge asset when it came to helping me navigate these murky waters. When it came to explaining what I should be doing and when, Tom was extremely clear and it put me at ease knowing I was in capable hands. For anybody who needs a personal injury lawyer, I can't recommend Tom and his firm enough!
I worked with Lucarelli & Castaldi after being hit on my daily bike commute, resulting in surgery and an extensive recovery period. I worked with Tom who was very kind and empathetic during the process. I felt fully supported and well advocated for. Also can't thank Cristina enough for how incredibly respectful and responsive she is. Many thanks to this team.
Owner response
Thank you so much for sharing this and for trusting us during such a challenging time. We’re really sorry you had to go through that experience, but we’re glad we could be there to support you. It means a lot to know our care, respect, and responsiveness made a difference for you. Wishing you continued healing and all the best moving forward.
Excellent result, exceeded all of our expectations. Thank you for your wonderful, and your staff. Communication was always perfect through our difficult time, I would recommend you always.
Owner response
Thank you so much! We really appreciate your trust and kind words. We’re so glad we could support you during a tough time. Wishing you all the best!
I was hit by a car on Riverside and 135 Street. I was knocked out, broke my neck, collarbone, bruised ribs, laceration on my knee which needed surgery, eyes knocked out of alignment, concussed-took a year to get better, and floaters in my eyes. I called Phil from the ambulance. He met me at the hospital and took care of the entire case from the police report to medical filings, all the way to getting me 100% of the policies. He was a pleasure to work with. I have referred 10 more cases from teammates and everyone is completely satisfied.
Owner response
Wow, thank you for sharing your story! We’re so glad Phil could be there for you every step of the way and help take care of everything while you focused on healing. It means so much to hear you felt supported—and we’re especially grateful for the referrals from you. Wishing you continued health and all the best!
I recently worked with Tom Lucarelli and I was completely satisfied. He was very informative and took extra time to explain things I didn’t understand. His service is impeccable, whenever I called his office he always responded and if he was in court and not available his assistant Cristina always addressed my concerns. I will never work with anyone else. I highly recommend him.
Owner response
Thank you so much! We’re so glad we could be there for you and make everything easier to understand. It means a lot to hear you felt supported, and we’re honored to have earned your trust and recommendation!
In May of 2015, the unthinkable happened, and before I knew it, I was in the hospital fighting for every breath after a tragic cycling accident. Works can not explain how difficult that was.
One thing I knew for a fact was that I had the full support of Phill & Tom of Lucarelli & Castaldi, LLP. They came to my hospital room and said... Coach, we got your back! That was exactly what they did.
Not only did they say that they had my back, they delivered in a big way on so many levels in a short period of time.
In most cases these things take years to settle.. That was not the case with Lucarelli & Castaldi, LLP... The professionalism and prompt response to my needs was above and beyond within months.
Thank you for all you do...
Very thankful.
Owner response
Thank you so much for sharing your experience. We are truly honored that we could support you during such a difficult time. It was our privilege to stand by your side and advocate for you, and we’re thrilled that our efforts made a meaningful difference. Your kind words mean a lot to Phil, Tom, and the entire team at Lucarelli & Castaldi, LLP. Wishing you continued health and success!
I had a cycling incident that led to multiple surgeries. After finding out about Lucarelli & Castaldi, I got in touch. Without a doubt, the best legal representation for injuries. Cristina was there every step of the way- I can't thank them enough.
Owner response
Thank you so much for sharing your experience. We’re truly sorry you went through such a difficult cycling incident, but we’re grateful you trusted us to help. Wishing you continued healing and all the best ahead.
While cycling in Mattituck, NY, I was struck by a driver who was not looking.
I fractured my spine, and had severe contusions to my elbow and glutes.
I reached out to Tom after seeing his ad in a cycling website, and he and Cristina, his paralegal, got to work immediately.
They thoroughly explained the process, and worked tirelessly to achieve the best settlement I could have hoped for.
Great communicators and very supportive of my needs during my recovery.
I highly recommend them in any legal matter where thoroughness and high competency is desirable.
Owner response
Thank you for placing your trust and confidence in our firm. We are pleased that you have received the outcome you deserve.
Had an awesome experience at this Firm. I dealt with Tom Lucarelli, he plays no games! The communication was always there no matter what time I called or whenever I needed something. The advice and guidance as well is unmatched. Also Cristina (paralegal) is the best person you can have handling the needs of your case, she handles everything swiftly and promptly and is also a phone call away! Highly recommend using this firm. We ended up receiving a 7 figure settlement in the end!
Owner response
Thank you Frankie for your trust in our firm. We are delighted with the outcome. Well deserved!
Found myself with a badly broken wrist after being doored on my roadbike in Brooklyn. A biker co-worker recommended me day of and now I'm recommending you.
ANY NYC BIKER who is in need of legal assistance should call Lucarelli & Castaldi.
They walked me through the process on the day of the accident and throughout the rest of the case. Always willing to hop of the phone and able to follow through.
Tom resolved my case quickly and to my advantage! His team was easy to work with and I'm very happy with the outcome. Would absolutely work with him again.
In Feb 2024, I was door'd while biking home from the gym. I had a puncture wound in my neck and was extremely lucky that I didn't die. I didn't know what to do as I've never been in this kind of situation before. I found Tom and his firm after a bit of research and they have been a huge asset when it came to helping me navigate these murky waters. When it came to explaining what I should be doing and when, Tom was extremely clear and it put me at ease knowing I was in capable hands. For anybody who needs a personal injury lawyer, I can't recommend Tom and his firm enough!