CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
Martin Law Firm P L Cape Coral Fl 68e65he0 review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Martin Law Firm P L Cape Coral Fl 68e65he0 so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.3
Total Reviews
73
PI Reviews
60
Text Reviews
73
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Martin Law Firm P L Cape Coral Fl 68e65he0.
What to check before you hire Martin Law Firm P L Cape Coral Fl 68e65he0
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.5
33 public reviews and 73 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from Brooke Anne: Feb 17, 2026 (170 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 158% of reviews
Most replies are brief or templated, so review text matters more than response style when comparing firms.
Martin Law Firm P L Cape Coral Fl 68e65he0 client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All73 reviews
4.3
Most recent written review from Brooke Anne: Feb 17, 2026 (170 days ago)
Written Reviews
73
Average Rating
4.30
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
73
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 73 of 73 written reviews.
1 star
11
2 star
1
3 star
0
4 star
4
5 star
57
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
I had the pleasure of working with Dustin Butler and Kelly Arroyo. going into this situation I had no clue where to start. Dustin helped walk me through the whole situation and was very transparent of all the options and and possible results to those options. Always answered in a timely manner and helped ease my anxious mind when needed. Kelly was great at keeping things organized and helping me with any tasks I had questions on. I was very happy to have them on my side, they were both professional and also very personable.
Matthew Stauffer is a very sloppy condescending lawyer. He didn't read my file at all apparently, He filed the lawsuit in Lee County, when the bulk of my father's estate is in Collier County, then four months into being on my case he gets around to file 'Notice to Creditors'. When I asked him why he didn't file sooner he blamed me for not telling him I was my father's personal representative! Well excuse me I'm not a lawyer and secondly it was right in my file that he failed to read, in the first codicil of my father's will! He then gets his ego bruised and drops me in the 11th hour after billing me $9k and I have nothing to show for it! He should be disbarred.
These guys are the best.Always there for you with full details all along the way.My attorney Dustin really got me out of a jam when I thought I had nowhere to go in my divorce case. We ended up winning from all angles. I’m very grateful. I 100% recommend these guys.
3800 to help me take down "child rape " next to my Google search results CONSIDERING IVE NEVER DONE ANYTHING LIKE THAT OR EVER BEEN ACCUSED OF ANYTHING LIKE THAT
My experience with Dustin Butler at Martin Law Firm started off well, but ended very disappointing. I was sent two draft letters that I never approved or used, yet I was charged $1,000 regardless.
I understand time is money. However, this was not the case. I received no response after my initial call back and left a VM for clarification on the letters, as they were not to my liking and as the client I have that right.
When I reached out for an explanation and requested a refund, I was ignored despite multiple attempts to follow up by email with both Mr. Butler and who I assume to be his assistant. I was only told that the work was completed.
Clients deserve clear communication and fair billing, especially when fees of this size are involved. Unfortunately, that was not my experience.
I paid another firm $500, which was half and within that had a better experience!
The law firm was a great help to me and got great results for my slip and fall case that happened at Walmart years ago. I highly recommend Eviana and Steve Martin. They are the best
Matthew Stauffer was wonderful handling our lawsuit during a very difficult time for us. He was respectful of our choices and did everything he could to make the process go as smoothly and quickly as he legally could. He stayed on top of everything; we rarely had to reach out to him to get an updated status of the case. He would always contact us as soon as there was a new development in our case. I would highly recommend him to anyone looking for representation.
Matthew Stauffer was wonderful. He diligently represented us in a difficult custodial case where we were seeking damages from a purported "POA". He was quick to respond and was easily able to explain all aspects of our case. Would highly recommend seeking his counsel in any matter.
I have used Attorney Dustin Butler twice in the matter of family law and he and his senior paralegal, Kelly are experts in their field. Dustin is knowledgeable, even keeled and brings great experience and discernment to the table. He is fair and ethical, rare qualities in a lawyer. I'm so happy I found Dustin and Kelly years ago, and would not hesitate to recommend them and their law firm to anyone involved in a complex family law matter.
Recently moved to Florida with my aunt who is living with us and needed some legal estate planning answers. They were so professional and honest about what we had and what we could do. They answered all of our questions and put my aunt at ease. Thank you!
hired Dustin Butler from Martin law firm for my divorce three years ago and man what a mistake. My ex started withholding my child from me and I asked Dustin to get visitation set up so he told me he put in a motion for temporary visitation. For three and a half months I checked in with him every week and he told me still no word I’m sure I’ll hear back by next week. So after 3.5 months I called him up and demanded to know right then what was going on so he looked into it and realized the he never submitted the motion like he told me he did. During this time my child was moved across the country on me and I’m now a long distance father with 20% visitation time and all the child support. Needless to say I fired him. The advice and service that I received from Dustin was horrible and cost me a lot. My advice is find an attorney that actually cares because that’s not Dustin, he’s clearly only in it for the money but isn’t worth half of what he charges.
I had the pleasure of working with Dustin Butler and Kelly Arroyo. going into this situation I had no clue where to start. Dustin helped walk me through the whole situation and was very transparent of all the options and and possible results to those options. Always answered in a timely manner and helped ease my anxious mind when needed. Kelly was great at keeping things organized and helping me with any tasks I had questions on. I was very happy to have them on my side, they were both professional and also very personable.
Matthew Stauffer is a very sloppy condescending lawyer. He didn't read my file at all apparently, He filed the lawsuit in Lee County, when the bulk of my father's estate is in Collier County, then four months into being on my case he gets around to file 'Notice to Creditors'. When I asked him why he didn't file sooner he blamed me for not telling him I was my father's personal representative! Well excuse me I'm not a lawyer and secondly it was right in my file that he failed to read, in the first codicil of my father's will! He then gets his ego bruised and drops me in the 11th hour after billing me $9k and I have nothing to show for it! He should be disbarred.
These guys are the best.Always there for you with full details all along the way.My attorney Dustin really got me out of a jam when I thought I had nowhere to go in my divorce case. We ended up winning from all angles. I’m very grateful. I 100% recommend these guys.