McArthur Law Firm Downtown Atlanta Atlanta Ga review signals at a glance

Following a severe car accident, McArthur Law Firm stepped in and completely managed our claim with incredible speed and professionalism. They resolved our case successfully before our medical treatments were even completed, allowing us to focus entirely on our recovery. Our attorney, Miss Holly, and her assistant, Miss Megan, provided outstanding support every step of the way. They handled every legal detail seamlessly, responded to all inquiries immediately, and treated us with the utmost respect. Additionally, Miss Patty did an incredible job executing the fast negotiation of our medical liens, maximizing what we received. They kept every promise and proved they truly care about clients over money. I give them my highest recommendation

After being in a terrible car accident, I wasn't sure what to do, but the amazing team at McArthur Law Firm took my case and had my back. They knew right away that the insurance money available from the at-fault driver and my own policy wouldn't be enough to make me completely whole again. Even knowing that, they fought to get me every last penny. Miss Holly and Miss Megan did their absolute best to collect all the money possible and answered every single question along the way. I was communicating with Miss Megan most of the time, and she would always sync up with Miss Holly to make sure we were taken care of. Miss Megan replied immediately and always knew how to comfort me and handle our requests. A special shout-out goes to Miss Patty, who negotiated my medical liens and handled everything super fast and professionally! This firm is incredibly friendly but always professional. While some lawyers only care about their money, this group cared about ME first. They keep their promises, and I highly recommend them to anyone who needs a lawyer who truly cares

I was involved in an accident. I chose McAuthor Law and was assigned Holly Stephens and from start to finish I was guided on what to expect and to do . From the medical treatment to replacement of my vehicle. They took away all the stress of the process of being in that kind of situation. Communication was great. The negotiating of the medical bills was excellent and exceeded all expectations. The process of the settlement was explained thoroughly. I appreciate all that was done on my behalf. I will definitely refer anyone in need of legal representation to Holly Stephens and McAuthor Law.

I cannot say enough wonderful things about McArthur Law Firm and the incredible team of Lindsey, Holly, and Katie. After a long two-year process negotiating with State Farm Insurance, they successfully brought my case to resolution—and they did so with professionalism, compassion, and unwavering dedication every step of the way. From day one, they were exceptionally attentive and made sure I never felt forgotten or in the dark. Communication was a constant strength: I received regular updates, clear explanations, and prompt responses whenever I had questions or concerns. No matter how small the issue, they took the time to address it thoughtfully and thoroughly. What truly sets Lindsey, Holly, and Katie apart is the genuine care they showed me as a client. Legal processes can be stressful and exhausting—especially over such a long period—but they consistently reassured me, advocated fiercely on my behalf, and treated me like more than just a case number. Their quick response time, attention to detail, and consistent feedback gave me complete confidence that I was in the best possible hands. I am incredibly grateful for their hard work and persistence, and I would wholeheartedly recommend McArthur Law Firm to anyone needing skilled, compassionate legal representation. Thank you, Lindsey, Holly, and Katie—you made a difficult journey feel manageable, and the successful outcome speaks volumes about your expertise and commitment.

Highly recommend Micheal is a great lawyer that’s on your side the entire time, very personable, and always keeping you updated about your case. I ended up walking away from my case very satisfied!

I turned over a myriad of medical documents and pictures to this law firm, sometimes as medical malpractice practice was happening in real-time. This law firm took almost 2 years before reviewing all the information I sent them. They were very irresponsible with returning my calls to them is another thing that concerned me about this law firm. They lost a medical records CD and swore that they never received it from me by mail. Until they found it sevrral months later!!! Needless to say after a long battle with injuries received by medical malpractice at Northside Forsyth Hospital in Cumming Georgia and as well medical negligence at Roswell Nursing inRoswell Georgia home my dear mother passed. I finally got to meet with the attorneys and listen as they retreated into telling me how much they would not be able to prove malpractice my mom suffered at this hospital and nursing home. This is with 100% proven injuries my mom suffered in these 2 medical facilities. For instance they left my mom alone and did not come check on her for several hours and she needed to go to the bathroom. No one came to assist her so she got out of the bed tripped over cords, fell and broke her arm. And she laid suffering on the floor for a couple hours not being able to get herself up off the floor because her arm was completely fractured. That just an example of the suffering she endured. I could go on and on, but I just want to state that this law fir was a complete no show, and disrespectful to my me, and my dead mother. I would not recommend this law firm to represent me in any case. They were a huge waste of time. I wish that I had performed more research and have chosen another attorney to represent me and my mother.

I feel very fortunate to have had the McArthur Law Firm and it's amazing legal team at my back through a truly difficult time. At every stage, from the beginning to the successful resolution of my case, I received responsive, and professional representation. My lawyers took the time to address every concern I had, and answer every question thoroughly, and in a timely manner. It was a tremendous relief to see them in action representing my needs. I would recommend the McArthur Law Firm to anyone without hesitation!

7 years. This is how long I had to deal with the car insurance company after my accident. It was a nightmare. No one took my case seriously. I was in debt from my medical bills. A lawyer who took my case messed up. Covid caused delays. The list goes on and on. I waited over 5 years and got nowhere. It was not until someone referred me to McArthur Law Firm did things start to change for me. Michael was assigned to my case and he promised to help me. He did. It took time for him to sort through all the mess which was not really his job but he did. He was very open with me about what he saw and felt confident he could get the insurance company to the table. He did. Car accident cases are nothing like what you see on tv. It is a long game. It is meant to break you down. You need a lawyer who cares and is willing to make things happen. Do not hesitate to work with this firm. Michael got me the settlement I needed to be made whole. This is all I wanted. I can't recommend him enough. If you are lucky enough to get him as your lawyer you will get the outcome you need.

Even though McArthur Law Firm wasn’t able to pick up my case, the staff still showed so much compassion towards me. The medical team went through thousands of pages of medical records for me, and maintained consistent contact throughout the whole process. After I was told they couldn’t take my case, Katie personally met with me, with two large stacks of records and even spent the time chatting with me. You can tell the staff here truly care about people and helping those in need. Thank you, Katie, for leaving such a great impression.

They're so slow and lack communication🙄

I had the pleasure of working with McArthur Law Firm during a very challenging time, and highly recommend them to anyone dealing with personal injury. From the very first interaction, the team was not only professional but also incredibly friendly and personal, making me feel valued and supported every step of the way. Lindsey Macon was a true standout. Her clear and concise communication made every aspect of the process easy to understand, and I always felt informed about what was happening. She took the time to answer my questions thoroughly, ensuring that I was never left in the dark. The outcome of my case was better than I could have ever imagined, and I credit Lindsey's expertise, dedication, and attention to detail for that result. She went above and beyond to make sure I received the best possible resolution. If you’re looking for an injury law firm with a team that genuinely cares and delivers outstanding results, I highly recommend Lindsey Macon and the incredible team at McArthur Law Firm. They exceeded all of my expectations!

Lindsey and her team are great! I was very satisfied with their work!!