CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
Melton Law Salt Lake City Ut review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Melton Law Salt Lake City Ut so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.8
Total Reviews
46
PI Reviews
41
Text Reviews
46
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Melton Law Salt Lake City Ut.
What to check before you hire Melton Law Salt Lake City Ut
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.9
367 public reviews and 46 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from J P: Mar 15, 2026 (141 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 12% of reviews
100% of the visible replies look at least somewhat personalized instead of fully templated.
Melton Law Salt Lake City Ut client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All46 reviews
4.8
Most recent written review from J P: Mar 15, 2026 (141 days ago)
Written Reviews
46
Average Rating
4.83
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
46
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 46 of 46 written reviews.
1 star
2
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
44
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Melton law will always pick up your call and or responds very quickly. Great attitudes and are extremely helpful and positive in these delicate situations. Excellent payment structure and they have a great team that compliment each other very well. Very impressed! Don't hesitate to give them a call.
Owner response
Thank you, J P, for the kind words and five-star review. We’re glad our team could be responsive, supportive, and helpful during a difficult time, and that our payment options met your needs. We appreciate your recommendation and will continue striving to provide excellent service.
Reliable. Dependable. Honest. And caring!! Sometimes hard to get ahold of him, but he's a lawyer. You won't be his only case he's dealing with. Cut him some slack!
This is the third time I’ve rewritten this review.
I initially left a 1-star review due to concerns about communication. After paying $4,400 to hire this firm, I made multiple calls to the office and asked the paralegal several times to have the attorney return my call, but I was unable to reach him.
After the 1-star review was posted, William called me for the first time. During that call, he was very aggressive and told me he would not continue working with us unless I changed my review.
During the conversation he also repeatedly told me that I was lying and that they had been communicating well. I asked if he had recordings of the calls so he could review them and see that my concerns about communication were genuine. After I told him I would change the review back to 5 stars, he apologized for his tone and said his business is “his baby.”
I’ve recently met other people who have had DUI’s and was told with confidence that there are better lawyers if you’re gonna pay the price. Don’t hire Melton Law. This review reflects my personal experience with communication during the early part of the process. I hope the firm improves responsiveness for future clients so situations like this can be avoided.
Owner response
Thank you for sharing your experience, and we are very sorry for the communication failures and for any distress caused by the interaction you described. We take allegations of unprofessional conduct seriously and are conducting an internal review to address the matter and ensure appropriate action. We are also implementing measures to improve responsiveness and client communication going forward. If you would like to discuss this directly, please contact our Client Relations Team at clientrelations@meltonlaw.com or call our office at the number listed on our website.
Our probation officer mentioned that it’s unusual for a privately hired attorney to withdraw right before the final hearing. I understand withdrawals can happen in certain situations, especially with court-appointed defense attorneys, but for a privately retained attorney to step away at the very last stage after being paid in full left us feeling unsupported and uncertain about what would happen next. This review reflects our personal experience. After paying $4k+ a one-star rating felt like the most honest way to reflect our experience.
If I could give Melton Law more than 5 stars I so would. Willam and Tony are very knowledgeable, understanding, forgiving and very patient. I have had a extremely difficult case and I aint been the easiest to work with due to physical health and trama and they didn't give up on me which I am grateful for. If you need a bull dog to fight your case Melton Law is a choice you won't ever regret.
Owner response
Thank you so much for your wonderful review and for trusting Melton Law with your case. We're grateful you recognized Willam and Tony's dedication, patience, and perseverance during such a difficult time. Supporting clients through challenging health and trauma issues is central to our work, and we're honored we could help. Your recommendation means a great deal to us.
They provided me peace of mind after one of the most stressful experiences of my life. I have never had any issues with the law before, and Tony truly cared and handled everything for me. I had major anxiety after being arrested for a DUI, but Tony took care of the entire process. I did not have to attend the hearing with the DLD, and he managed everything so my license was not suspended. I was even reimbursed for the impound.
Thank you so much. Rick was also very helpful throughout the process.
Owner response
Thank you, Renee. We’re so glad Tony and Rick could guide you through such a stressful time and secure a positive outcome, including keeping your license active and getting the impound reimbursed. Providing peace of mind and attentive care is our top priority, and your kind words mean a lot. If you ever need assistance in the future please don’t hesitate to reach out.
William represented my husband very well. He got most of our charges dropped. And we’re very happy with the outcome. I give him ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (10 stars)
Owner response
Thank you, Dakota, for the wonderful 10-star review. We’re thrilled William represented your husband so well and was able to get most of the charges dropped. We appreciate your trust and are glad you’re happy with the outcome; please reach out if you need our assistance again.
Amazing work! These guys helped me out a lot. They helped drop my DUI charges to a wreckless driving. 100 percent reccomend!
Owner response
Thank you so much, Diego. We’re very glad we could help secure that reduction and appreciate you trusting our team. Your recommendation means a lot to us.
The entire staff at this firm was enormously helpful. I was, at all times,able to speak with somebody about the details and potential of my defense. Jamie was attentive and consistently encouraging. When it came down to the wire, Tony Robite generated a rational and favorable outcome.
Thank God it's over without a lot of fuss,
Charlie G
Owner response
Thank you, Charlie, for the kind words and for trusting our team. We’re thrilled Jamie and Tony could support you and help secure a favorable outcome. Your recognition of our staff’s accessibility and encouragement means a lot. Please reach out if you need anything in the future.
Did a good job with my case And got me the best possible outcome. Overall, quite reliable
Owner response
Thank you, Luke. I’m glad we could secure the best possible outcome for your case and that you found our team reliable. We appreciate your trust and kind words. If you ever need assistance again or want to refer someone, we’re here to help.
Melton Law was absolutely fabulous with my case! They were very supportive and understanding with my situations. They represented me on two occasions and walked me through everything I needed to do on both circumstances, and the second case was dropped. I have nothing but positive things to say about Melton Law, thank you so much Tony and the rest of the law firm in representing me and getting me the best results possible! I highly recommend Melton Law to anyone who is looking for an amazing defense attorney! Thank you again!
Owner response
Thank you for your wonderful review and for trusting Melton Law with your cases. We're thrilled you felt supported and that the second case was dropped — Tony and the entire team appreciate your kind words and recommendation. It was our privilege to assist you through both matters, and we’re glad we could achieve the best possible results. If you ever need our help again, we’re here for you.
I am new to Utah and was not aware of how tickets are handled in this state. That caused some uncertainty and stress for me; nonetheless Tony was a great advocate for me. I had the best possible outcome, in my opinion. I would definitely recommend Melton Law for litigation concerning a speeding ticket.
Owner response
Thank you for choosing Melton Law and for sharing your experience. We're glad Tony could guide you through Utah's ticket process and secure the best possible outcome. It means a lot that you would recommend us for speeding ticket litigation. If you need anything further as you settle into Utah, we're here to help.
Melton law will always pick up your call and or responds very quickly. Great attitudes and are extremely helpful and positive in these delicate situations. Excellent payment structure and they have a great team that compliment each other very well. Very impressed! Don't hesitate to give them a call.
Reliable. Dependable. Honest. And caring!! Sometimes hard to get ahold of him, but he's a lawyer. You won't be his only case he's dealing with. Cut him some slack!
This is the third time I’ve rewritten this review.
I initially left a 1-star review due to concerns about communication. After paying $4,400 to hire this firm, I made multiple calls to the office and asked the paralegal several times to have the attorney return my call, but I was unable to reach him.
After the 1-star review was posted, William called me for the first time. During that call, he was very aggressive and told me he would not continue working with us unless I changed my review.
During the conversation he also repeatedly told me that I was lying and that they had been communicating well. I asked if he had recordings of the calls so he could review them and see that my concerns about communication were genuine. After I told him I would change the review back to 5 stars, he apologized for his tone and said his business is “his baby.”
I’ve recently met other people who have had DUI’s and was told with confidence that there are better lawyers if you’re gonna pay the price. Don’t hire Melton Law. This review reflects my personal experience with communication during the early part of the process. I hope the firm improves responsiveness for future clients so situations like this can be avoided.