Personal Injury
Unknown
Very unprofessional while speaking about my situation.
Analyzing Data...
Lawyer Review Intelligence
CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Nobles Decarolis Rochester Ny so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Nobles Decarolis Rochester Ny.
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
35 public reviews and 23 written reviews.
Most recent written review from David Young: Feb 4, 2026 (129 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Replies on 6% of reviews
100% of the visible replies look at least somewhat personalized instead of fully templated.
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from David Young: Feb 4, 2026 (129 days ago)
Written Reviews
15
Average Rating
4.73
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
15
Assigned Tags (51)
Showing 15 of 23 written reviews.
1 star
1
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
14
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Very unprofessional while speaking about my situation.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Straight honest and no bull... THANK YOU FOR YOUR ADVICE
Personal Injury
Unknown
Jim and his staff were amazing. Always there for questions and provided the best service.
Owner response
We truly appreciate your feedback and are delighted to hear our staff provided you with excellent and confidential service. We thank you for entrusting our firm with your case.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Brian was absolutely wonderful. He was very knowledgeable and extremely thoughtful and helpful, throughout the entire process. I can't imagine having gone through the process without him.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Brian DeCarolis was very attentive to my case. He was very responsive, and understands the law which is very important. During our case he understood everything the judge and DA threw at him. I was beyond happy with our outcome.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Brian is a terrific counsel. He was professional, easy to work with, courteous, knowledgeable, and provided me with timely updates, sound, unvarnished, and honest advice throughout my case. Thanks to his guidance, I got a positive outcome. I'm forever grateful to him and Nobles & DeCarolis. Thank you, Brian!
Personal Injury
Unknown
I have dealt with many attorneys over the last 30 years. Brian DeCarolis is one of the best if not the best. He helped me with a very serious case and it was over in two months rather than a year +. The results were better than I could have hoped for. I would use him again if the need ever arises.
Personal Injury
Unknown
Brian was excellent. He was extremely knowledgeable and thorough during the entire process. Brian represented me on two separate cases and if there was ever a question he would provide an answer promptly. My phone calls were always returned before the end day. I never felt out of place or misinformed. His commitment to his clients is impeccable. Highly recommended.
Personal Injury
Unknown
I wish I were able to give James Nobles more than 5 starts! Not only is he brilliant & knows the law like no other, but he is attentive & makes you feel like he’s your only client. He’s a true diamond in the ruff and I have referred him more times than I can count!
Personal Injury
Unknown
James Nobles representation was professional, kept me advised of process and proceedings, and I was happy with the resolution of my case.
Personal Injury
Unknown
James was very professional and helped me with every step of my case. He also answered any questions I had and gave me tons of good advice. Thanks to him I walked away from a few charges barely touched. Would highly recommend him to anybody. He is worth every cent
Personal Injury
Unknown
Not your typical attorney. Doesn't promise you the world until he gets your retainer and then try to talk you back down. Nobles does what he says and says what he does.
Most recent written review from David Young: Feb 4, 2026 (129 days ago)
Mentioned in 9 reviews, with an average 5.0-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
Mentioned in 8 reviews, with an average 5.0-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
Mentioned in 9 reviews, with an average 4.6-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
9 reviews touch this theme, including 1 clearly negative mentions and 0 mixed mentions.
7 reviews touch this theme, including 1 clearly negative mentions and 0 mixed mentions.
21 reviews currently have no visible owner response, so the written feedback matters more than response style.
I do not recommend Brian DeCarolis and not quite sure how anyone who has been defended by him with anything larger than a minor offense could rank him much better than 2 stars at best. As a local businessman with over 25 years of experience working with numerous attorneys, this was the least effective legal representation I have encountered. After paying a substantial retainer, I received minimal substantive work. At one point, Mr. DeCarolis declined to appear in court on my behalf, stating the matter was “too last minute,” despite having already been retained. Requests for a clear legal strategy, defense framework, or explanation of approach were repeatedly met with vague responses such as “let’s worry about now.” When court appearances did occur, there was no apparent preparation or defined course of action. The representation appeared reactive rather than deliberate. When asked why potential defenses or outcomes were not discussed, Mr. DeCarolis stated he was “not one for hypotheticals.” In my experience, anticipating legal scenarios and discussing strategy is a basic expectation of competent counsel. In my opinion, a public defender would have provided greater structure, preparation, and advocacy than what I experienced here, without the associated financial cost. The only professional and consistently responsive individual involved was his legal assistant, Dena. Unfortunately, that did not offset the overall lack of preparation and direction demonstrated by the attorney. Based solely on my experience, I would strongly advise others to seek alternative representation before committing funds or wasting a call to this office.
Very unprofessional while speaking about my situation.
Brian' is a savage in the cort room he has the court system figured out. Brian has been a part of my life for many years from him playing against me being a D.A in Greece when i was a youth, which many do not know he played both sides of the law as a magnificent, chest plaining mindset of his he is my type of attorney . I chose brian because i'm a very mental person and I thought about how he mastered both sides of being a D.a and then becoming a criminal defense attorney, the guy is a complete genius. He knows every step the d a wolf taken, he will be in front of the da to jab at everything they throw at him. Cool ,com .&collective with one thing on his mind win and get job done. In every step of the year in half of the cases we had great communication, He is straightforward.He does not sell you a story with his high ranking lawyer presence you realize your in the best hands money can buy reamber you get what you pay for that how the world works 💪 wouldn't be here today with out Brian's &james money well spent his professionalism is out the roof