CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
Polsky Shouldice And Rosen P.C. Queens Ny review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for Polsky Shouldice And Rosen P.C. Queens Ny so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.8
Total Reviews
42
PI Reviews
40
Text Reviews
42
Most common themes
recommendationattorney praiseclient focus
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from Polsky Shouldice And Rosen P.C. Queens Ny.
What to check before you hire Polsky Shouldice And Rosen P.C. Queens Ny
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.7
202 public reviews and 42 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from Peter Allen: Feb 6, 2026 (175 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 11% of reviews
Most replies are brief or templated, so review text matters more than response style when comparing firms.
Polsky Shouldice And Rosen P.C. Queens Ny client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All42 reviews
4.8
Most recent written review from Peter Allen: Feb 6, 2026 (175 days ago)
Written Reviews
40
Average Rating
4.80
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
40
Assigned Tags (79)
Showing 40 of 42 written reviews.
1 star
2
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
38
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
My original workers comp firm was no help at all. I made a call here and they invited me in for a visit 2 days later. They addressed concerns I didn’t even know were relevant or possible. I knew in the first 5 minutes I was in great hands. So glad I was recommended here.
Mark Polsky has been my workers comp attorney since 1999. Since I work at 2 jobs, 75 hour work week can expose you to many work hazards. Hurt multiple times at each job, Mr. Polsky and his team was available to guide me at every step. At 1 job I sustained an injury that has required multiple surgeries and insurance refusing to pay. At every court date, Polsky fighting for my rights. My family and I are thankful for their services. Sincerely Jose Rivera
Communication (positive)Needing a Lawyer (positive)Holistic Advocacy (positive)No ResponseSentiment: positiveDetailed StoryLikely Client Experience
0/10 extremely unprofessional experience
I met with lawyer Rosen today for a workers’ compensation case, and I was shocked at how dismissive and unhelpful he was. He wouldn’t answer any of my questions, his response to everything was “I don’t know” or “I can’t answer that.” When I asked for basic guidance about what to expect or how to handle my financial situation since I’ve been out of work for a month due to an injury I sustained on the job, he completely brushed me off and said, “We’re not the right fit for you,” then walked me out.
For someone coming in with their first workers’ comp case, the least he could’ve done was explain the process or show a bit of compassion. Instead, he was rude, impatient, and made me feel like I was wasting his time. I would absolutely not recommend Mr. Rosen to anyone. You’re better off representing yourself, at least that way you know someone’s actually fighting for you.
Owner response
We never like to get a bad review, and it is disheartening to get one after a free consultation. As an attorney it is my obligation to explain to you what your rights are, and what you would be entitled to based on your injuries. It is more important that I tell you what NYS Workers' Compensation would cover as opposed to telling you what you want to hear. While you may not have liked my answers to your questions they were the correct answers under the law, and I would rather you left my office unhappy with what the system provides as opposed to being misinformed. You were asking me who would pay for certain bills that you would incur in your life that you that you were concerned you would have trouble meeting. Some of these were things that the NYS WC law does not provide for or cover. There is nothing our firm can do to change how the law is written. Based on our free consultation I realized that we would not be able to provide results that you were hoping for, which is why we passed on taking you on as a client. <br>Regardless, I wish you the very best of luck in your recovery and your claim.
Communication (negative)Process Transparency (negative)Choosing Right Firm (negative)Case # Treatment (negative)Needing a Lawyer (negative)PersonalizedSentiment: negativeGeneric ReviewLikely Non-Client / Consultation
My husband, Richie Draeger used this Lawyer team he says Mr Polosky was the best attorney he has ever experienced working with. He highly recommends him his integrity, his degree of expertise him knowledge and dedication to not giving up was an experience. Will never forget we thank you so much five stars all around Lawyer. We highly recommend him, especially for Workmens Comp cases! Thank you, Mr. Polosky!!!!❤️
Owner response
Thank you for this amazing review. It was our pleasure to work with you!
I experienced a devastating injury while at work that changed life as I’ve always known it. I was left unable to participate in the things that I’ve always enjoyed and loved most. This experience left me confused and completely vulnerable to the insurance companies. Several friends recommended Polsky Shouldice & Rosen as a reputable Workers Compensation Law Firm.
I cannot begin to express the ease that I felt under the watchful eye of this law firm! Mr. Donald Shouldice’s caring & compassionate nature redefines every stigma attached to his profession. I feel so at peace knowing that I am represented by a group of professionals that see me as an individual and will fight for me until the end.
I am so grateful to this fine group and to those that recommended Polsky Shouldice & Rosen ( the Best Workers Compensation Law Firm on Long Island)!
Owner response
Thank you for this amazing review. Getting hurt at work is so traumatic. I am happy we were able to help you navigate your claim. It was our pleasure to work with you!
Choosing Right Firm (positive)Case # Treatment (positive)Needing a Lawyer (positive)Holistic Advocacy (positive)Semi-PersonalizedSentiment: positiveDetailed StoryLikely Client Experience
Show all assigned tags (18)
case:workers compensationstage:post_verdictresponse:semi_personalizedsentiment:positivestory:storyclient:likely_clientpi:yesdepth:essaydimension:ChoosingFirmdimension-sentiment:ChoosingFirm:positivedimension:CaseNumberTreatmentdimension-sentiment:CaseNumberTreatment:positivedimension:NeedingLawyerdimension-sentiment:NeedingLawyer:positivedimension:HolisticAdvocacydimension-sentiment:HolisticAdvocacy:positivecompetitor:workers compensation law firmcompetitor:best workers compensation law firm
I had an excellent experience working with Polsky, Shouldice and Rosen PC on my workers’ compensation case. From the beginning, they were compassionate, responsive, and extremely knowledgeable about the process. They took the time to explain my rights, answer all my questions, and kept me updated every step of the way. Their dedication and professionalism made a difficult time much easier to navigate. Thanks to their hard work, I received the compensation I deserved, and I couldn’t be more grateful. I highly recommend to anyone dealing with a workplace injury.
Owner response
Thank you for this great review. It is is very much appreciated. It was our pleasure to work with you!
Communication (positive)Process Transparency (positive)Needing a Lawyer (positive)Holistic Advocacy (positive)Semi-PersonalizedSentiment: positiveDetailed StoryLikely Client Experience
Thanks! I appreciate the work you did on my case. The company tried hard to disassociate themselves from my work-related injury, but you fought back incredibly. That is why I was able to get my therapies, surgery, and compensation. So I'll definitely keep recommending you to former coworkers and everyone around me who faces similar situations to the one I went through. Thanks to Marilyn, Anne Baez, and all of the personnel involved with my case. 🫶
Owner response
Thank you for this kind review. I am glad you liked our Thank you note. It is clients like you that make our firm what it is, and we are so appreciative that you trust people you care about with us!
Lowball Pressure (positive)Needing a Lawyer (positive)Semi-PersonalizedSentiment: positiveDetailed StoryLikely Client Experience
My original workers comp firm was no help at all. I made a call here and they invited me in for a visit 2 days later. They addressed concerns I didn’t even know were relevant or possible. I knew in the first 5 minutes I was in great hands. So glad I was recommended here.
Mark Polsky has been my workers comp attorney since 1999. Since I work at 2 jobs, 75 hour work week can expose you to many work hazards. Hurt multiple times at each job, Mr. Polsky and his team was available to guide me at every step. At 1 job I sustained an injury that has required multiple surgeries and insurance refusing to pay. At every court date, Polsky fighting for my rights. My family and I are thankful for their services. Sincerely Jose Rivera