Definitely recommend
Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Request a free case review from Sgarlato & Sgarlato PLLC in Staten Island, New York.
Sgarlato & Sgarlato PLLC
Staten Island Personal Injury Lawyer — 22 Client Reviews Analyzed
4.6(22 reviews)Sgarlato & Sgarlato PLLC is a Personal Injury law firm in Staten Island, NY, located at 1444 Clove Rd and reachable at +1718-273-7900. Clients have rated the firm 4.6 out of 5 across 22 public Google reviews, 16 of which include written feedback. The most recent written review is from John Balzer on Apr 10, 2025 (462 days ago).
What reviewers consistently praise: care for the whole situation, communication and updates, and clear next steps. These themes surfaced across dozens of reviews when CrashStory analyzed sentiment and case-experience dimensions on this firm's Google reviews. Compare these against any other firm you're considering — most attorneys have only two or three themes reviewers consistently return to.
How we compiled this: CrashStory aggregates public Google reviews, Colorado crash records from CDOT and local agencies, and firm-provided profile data. We do not endorse any firm. Review intelligence scores are derived from automated sentiment and theme analysis of public reviews — treat them as one signal among many, not a verdict.
22 reviews
Years Experience
Practice Areas
Office Location
Consultation
Each button opens a new tab with a ready-made prompt that references this CrashStory page and the key facts already shown here.
Sgarlato & Sgarlato PLLC is a personal injury law firm serving clients in Staten Island, New York, located at 1444 Clove Rd 10301.
Review evidence: Clients have left 22 public Google reviews averaging 4.6 out of 5, 16 of which include written feedback. CrashStory scores 12 client-experience dimensions across this review corpus — compare side-by-side with other Staten Island, New York firms before you decide.
Quick signals: the Google Business profile for this firm is verified; 21 photos are public on Google; contact the firm to ask about consultation fees.
Contact Sgarlato & Sgarlato PLLC at (718) 273-7900 or visit sgarlatolaw.com for a free case review.
22 public reviews and 16 written reviews.
Most recent written review from John Balzer: Apr 10, 2025 (462 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
No public owner responses yet
There are no visible owner replies in the current review corpus.
Most recent written review from John Balzer: Apr 10, 2025 (462 days ago)
Mentioned in 10 reviews, with an average 5.0-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
Mentioned in 6 reviews, with an average 5.0-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
Mentioned in 5 reviews, with an average 5.0-star rating when clients talk about this theme.
16 reviews currently have no visible owner response, so the written feedback matters more than response style.
The newest written review in this dataset is from Apr 10, 2025 (462 days ago). Compare that recency with the other firms you are considering.
Definitely recommend
Very professional, honest and fast working peoples. Everyone is very polite and helpful. I recommend strongly.
Gina and her entire office team are very professional and always been there for my family when we need them or to answer questions. I would never consider anyone else to handle our legal affairs!
1444 Clove Rd, Staten Island, NY 10301
| Date | Location | Severity | Distance | Details |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Feb 10, 2026 | STEUBEN ST & WINDERMERE RD Two-Vehicle Crash·2 vehicles | Minor Injury 2 injured | 1.42 mi | View → |
| Feb 10, 2026 | & 164 CANAL ST Two-Vehicle Crash·2 vehicles | Minor Injury 1 injured | 1.44 mi | View → |
| Feb 6, 2026 | RICHMOND RD & FOUR CORNERS RD Two-Vehicle Crash·2 vehicles | Minor Injury 2 injured | 1.49 mi | View → |
| Feb 4, 2026 | HYLAN BLVD & PARKINSON AVE Two-Vehicle Crash·2 vehicles | Minor Injury 2 injured | 1.33 mi | View → |
| Feb 3, 2026 | & 572 BARD AVE Single-Vehicle Crash·1 vehicle | Minor Injury 1 injured | 1.2 mi | View → |
Recent written Google reviews from the last 30 days appear first. Older written reviews stay available through pagination and filtering.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from John Balzer: May 8, 2026 (69 days ago)
Written Reviews
10
Average Rating
5.00
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
10
Older Archive
10
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 10 of 10 written reviews.
1 star
0
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
10
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
John Balzer
Personal Injury
Unknown
Definitely recommend
Muhammad saqib Ayub
Personal Injury
Unknown
Very professional, honest and fast working peoples. Everyone is very polite and helpful. I recommend strongly.
Gregory Roperti
Personal Injury
Unknown
Gina and her entire office team are very professional and always been there for my family when we need them or to answer questions. I would never consider anyone else to handle our legal affairs!
Jillian Cancel
Personal Injury
Unknown
I had the pleasure of working with Mahnoor after an accident, and I couldn’t be more satisfied with the experience. From the initial consultation to the final settlement, Mahnoor and the whole team at Sgarlato & Sgarlato demonstrated exceptional professionalism, empathy, and expertise. They went above and beyond to ensure that I felt supported and informed throughout the entire process. If you need a personal injury lawyer who is knowledgeable, compassionate, and relentless in advocating for your rights, I highly recommend.
Evergreen Art studio
Personal Injury
Unknown
Great service. The staff is very professional and efficient. Office is nice which gives client good feeling. Totally recommend to other clients
Rose of Sharon
Personal Injury
Unknown
One of the BEST Law firms on the island . Mrs. Gina and her team are wonderful, and I'm so thankful I was introduced to them. The best decision I ever made!!! Thank you, everyone, for all your hard work. It's truly appreciated. Wishing you success and health for the New Year. God bless!!💓
cara trentadue
Personal Injury
Unknown
It was in 2014 when I was involved in an accident where a tractor trailer was making a left turn trying to beat the light I was already stopped for in the right lane. This guy slammed me in the right side and rear ended me at the same time. Initially I thought I came out of this unscathed. It wasn't until an hour later my neck and jaw started feeling like they were plugged into an electrical socket. it took 4 years to actually pin point my injuries because they were all related to the whiplash and the impact caused by the truck, and JAW injuries are very hard to diagnose. When I met Gina she was compassionate to my injuries but tough when she needed to be. Her staff are all very knowledgeable, warm and friendly. The trucking company hired a hot shot firm who minimized the case and basically tried to ignore our claims. Gina stood for none of it, she made demands as to CDL laws and implored them to respond until recently they requested an arbitration to discuss a possible settlement. These people low balled her and wasted a whole day of traveling in pain. Gina never once faltered, she ended the meeting and proceeded to trial the next day. After offering less than 1/4 of what was originally offered Gina negotiated a substantial settlement. Thanks to Gina's attention to details and refusal to sell me short I was able to put this mess behind me. I highly recommend Gina for many reasons. She is smart, bold and courageous while maintaining a realistic idea of BOTH perspectives which I feel gives her an edge over the other pompous ecumenical personal injury attorneys out there. Gina is grounded and becomes more like family than just another Attorney. I would trust her with my life. She also helped a friend of mine with a very complicated title issue and got my friend full compensation for a title error that created a tax issue on her condo. There are not many Attorneys who could have done that and she did.
Sydney Dagostino
Personal Injury
Unknown
I highly recommend Sgarlato & Sgarlato! They are knowledgeable, professional, and always available to answer any questions. They have a great understanding of the law and are always willing to go the extra mile to ensure that their clients get the best possible outcome. Highly recommend!
Deborah A. Genovese, CPA
Personal Injury
Unknown
Gina Sgarlato is an exceptional attorney. Everything you are looking for and expect from a law office can be found within her organization. From start to finish her office staff offered first class service. We used her for an out of state closing and received quality client service from start to finish. She not only is knowledgable and patient but is not afraid to take the time to explain what is happening every step of the way throughout the process. I will not only use this office again but will recommend them to others as well.
Gina Runfola
Personal Injury
Unknown
Professional, smart, honest and responsive. Highly recommend Sgarlato & Sgarlato.
Other personal injury lawyers near this office
new york and new jersey dental malpractice law lutfy & santora
Lutfy and Santora, Attorneys at Law
Orin Cohen Law
Browse all personal injury lawyers serving Staten Island, New York.
View All Staten Island LawyersCompare nearby firms, browse city lawyer directories, and read case-type guides before you decide who to contact.
Showing fallback links while lawyer performance data refreshes.