CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
The Law Office Of Anthony R Scifo P.C. Elgin Il review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for The Law Office Of Anthony R Scifo P.C. Elgin Il so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.5
Total Reviews
42
PI Reviews
15
Text Reviews
42
Most common themes
DNA Testing
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from The Law Office Of Anthony R Scifo P.C. Elgin Il.
What to check before you hire The Law Office Of Anthony R Scifo P.C. Elgin Il
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.5
44 public reviews and 42 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from Joe Monsalud II: Jan 15, 2026 (203 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
No public owner responses yet
There are no visible owner replies in the current review corpus.
The Law Office Of Anthony R Scifo P.C. Elgin Il client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All42 reviews
4.5
Most recent written review from Joe Monsalud II: Jan 15, 2026 (203 days ago)
Written Reviews
42
Average Rating
4.52
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
42
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 42 of 42 written reviews.
1 star
5
2 star
0
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
37
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
I had the chance to work with Tony for a couple of events. 1st event was when my mom passed. My mom didn't have a will and things needed to go to probate. I called up Tony's office to meet up and he made the probate process with my sister and I the easiest process. Tony took the time to sit down to explain all the processes that needed to happen in order to take care of everything. Tony was very accessible and answered all our questions. 2nd event was getting my wifes name on the deed to our house. Again easy process. He emailed me all the forms i had to print, fill out and sign, with detailed instructions on what to do. Tony pulled through again and all it took was a simple phone call. Thank you Tony for everything!! A +++++++ Service. Highly recommend Tony for anything family law related that you need taken care of!
Tony is simply the best! After a long battle with my now ex husband, I feel like I can finally breathe! Everything was a battle with my ex and Tony was in the front lines for me every step of the way. I never even had to step foot in a court room.
If you’re reading this because you’re looking for an attorney, look no further.
I had the privilege of working with The Law Office of Anthony R. Scifo, P.C., and I cannot speak highly enough of the exceptional service and care I received from Tony. He represented me in a deeply personal matter concerning the care and well-being of my mother, who means the world to me. From the very beginning, Tony demonstrated not only his unparalleled legal expertise but also a compassion and understanding that made an incredibly difficult time much easier to navigate.
Throughout the entire process, Tony was always available to listen, offering not just legal guidance but a comforting and reassuring presence during moments of uncertainty. His dedication to my mother's health and my peace of mind went beyond the standard expectations of an attorney. Tony consistently made me feel as though I was his most important client, taking the time to address my concerns and fears, no matter how big or small.
What truly sets Tony apart is the rare combination of professionalism and genuine personal care. It’s evident that he is not just an attorney, but a person who genuinely cares about the individuals he represents. In a world where it can be hard to find trust, Tony offers a sense of reliability and dedication that cannot be measured in monetary terms.
I wholeheartedly recommend Tony to anyone in need of legal counsel. His ability to exceed expectations in the legal field, while also bringing a personal, human touch to the experience, is a rare and invaluable trait. I will forever be grateful for his support during such a challenging time, and I am confident anyone who works with him will experience the same outstanding care and professionalism.
Thank you, Tony, for everything.
Anthony Scifo is still assisting us in court and is an excellent attorney. I would recommend him highly. Kind, considerate and caring towards the family and accuracy with the case. Contacts you immediately with all regards. A-1
Tony was amazing with helping me through every step of my divorce. We went through a few bumps but Tony was very patient and very communicative. Couldn’t ask for a better lawyer to handle my case and such a short period of time despite the bumps in the road.
Thank you for you and your team’s amazing and professional work.
Not just a great Attorney that looks out for your best interest but is also a great person that I consider a friend. I have been a client of Tony’s for over 7 years from preparing both mine and my wife’s Will’s and Power of Attorney’s to representing me in a Guardianship and a Probate case.
This time it was the Probate case Tony helped me and my sister through since we were having issues with the Executor of the Estate. Tony has always been professional in everything he did if it was a meeting in his office to presenting in front of the Judge. Tony always explained what was going on and we always felt he had our backs.
It also helped that he enjoys a good cheesecake that me and my wife make for him and his Associates.
Hiring a lawyer as a contractor can feel daunting—you never really know how things will turn out, even when you’re certain you’re in the right. From the start, Matthew Robinson put me at ease. He combined sharp legal expertise with the kind of steady reassurance that made the entire process far less stressful.
Matthew Robinson isn’t just an outstanding lawyer—experienced, knowledgeable, and brilliant at what he does—he’s also a genuinely good person and a family man who clearly found the profession he was meant for. He guided me with honesty, clarity, and yes, even a few well-timed puns that made tough moments lighter.
I’m deeply grateful for his work and the way he helped me through this. I would recommend Matthew Robinson without hesitation to anyone in need of not only an exceptional attorney, but also someone you can truly trust to have your back.
Tony is the best. He will fight for you. Im a single mother to a four year old and I was taken to family court after my ex had not been involved for 2 years. I tried legal aid, FREE legal help, but they did not do anything for me. Tony moved mountains for my little girl and I. Ik lawyers can be expensive but he will fight for u, and He will make sure you see the results. He always came to court organized, and kept me updated. On top of everything he knows the court room. He has had multiple court cases in the family court room I was in and was familiar with the judge. He also had worked several court cases against my ex's lawyer. He knew what he was up against and what to expect from the opposing party. I can not stress what a difference this made.
Tony was very helpful with my divorce process. He is very prompt with his communication, will tell you what is in your best interests (even if its uncomfortable), and was fairly priced.
Update review: (07/2025) I was just recently brought back to court by my ex, I immediately contacted Anthony Scifo again, and he was willing and able to help and represented me again through this process regarding child support.
This matter i could have probably done myself without using him, however things that should have been simple before in court never were cut and dry with the other side, and I knew Anthony Scifo and his team would show up ready for anything, put my children's and my best interest first and above all be honest with me about what going on, and what route is best to take to have the overall best outcome and get it done. The outcome was better than what I was told I would get from the otherside if I fought his demands in court, and I had the peace of mind knowing thar everything would be handled through my attorney and his team so during the process I didnt have to stress and be anxious speaking to my ex.
So much gratitude and praise to Anthony and his team yet again, I highly recommend this firm to anyone in need of an amazing, hard working, honest and knowledgeable attorney!
When I needed to start my divorce process, I had no clue where to look and start. I blindly choose the office of Anthony Scifo, and I'm so glad I did!
Upon meeting Anthony, I explained my situation, he seemed genuine and caring and I felt I found the right attorney to handle my case.
What should have been a very simple divorce, became a nightmare, however due to the high caliber work ethic of Anthony Scifo and his team, it was way smoother than I anticipated, even with years of back and forth with the other side.
Anthony fought countless hours, days, months and years for my children and me, he always listened, was honest and straight forward with the process and possibly outcomes. He's a lawyer who really cares and becomes invested to help, protect and fight the good fight for his clients.
I will be forever grateful for him and his law office for helping me, never questioning 9r doubting me while standing with me during one of the hardest times in my life.
I highly recommend anyone to hire Anthony, you won't regret it. I can't stress enough that beyond his work and knowledge of the system and years of expiernce in the field , it's hard to find a lawyer who cares like him and his team. Make the best decision during difficult personal times and give this law firm a call, you won't regret it!
I am so glad that I trusted attorney Anthony Scifo and Matthew Robinson with my case. Their levels of expertise are top notch as well as their professionalism. They were successful in reopening a complex injury case for me that was dismissed over 13 years ago due to the negligence of another attorney I had representing me at that time. Unlike that previous attorney I had, Tony and Matthew have integrity and will conduct proper due diligence of your case. I appreciated their flexibility in willing to extend their business hours whenever I needed to meet with them. He helped me receive monetary damages. Tony, alongside his paralegal Lupe, answered any and all inquiries I had in a timely manner and provided regular status updates of how my case was going. I was satisfied with the resolution as I received a fair settlement and actually more than I ever expected. Huge thanks to Mr. Scifo’s law office for going above and beyond.
I had the chance to work with Tony for a couple of events. 1st event was when my mom passed. My mom didn't have a will and things needed to go to probate. I called up Tony's office to meet up and he made the probate process with my sister and I the easiest process. Tony took the time to sit down to explain all the processes that needed to happen in order to take care of everything. Tony was very accessible and answered all our questions. 2nd event was getting my wifes name on the deed to our house. Again easy process. He emailed me all the forms i had to print, fill out and sign, with detailed instructions on what to do. Tony pulled through again and all it took was a simple phone call. Thank you Tony for everything!! A +++++++ Service. Highly recommend Tony for anything family law related that you need taken care of!
Tony is simply the best! After a long battle with my now ex husband, I feel like I can finally breathe! Everything was a battle with my ex and Tony was in the front lines for me every step of the way. I never even had to step foot in a court room.
If you’re reading this because you’re looking for an attorney, look no further.
I had the privilege of working with The Law Office of Anthony R. Scifo, P.C., and I cannot speak highly enough of the exceptional service and care I received from Tony. He represented me in a deeply personal matter concerning the care and well-being of my mother, who means the world to me. From the very beginning, Tony demonstrated not only his unparalleled legal expertise but also a compassion and understanding that made an incredibly difficult time much easier to navigate.
Throughout the entire process, Tony was always available to listen, offering not just legal guidance but a comforting and reassuring presence during moments of uncertainty. His dedication to my mother's health and my peace of mind went beyond the standard expectations of an attorney. Tony consistently made me feel as though I was his most important client, taking the time to address my concerns and fears, no matter how big or small.
What truly sets Tony apart is the rare combination of professionalism and genuine personal care. It’s evident that he is not just an attorney, but a person who genuinely cares about the individuals he represents. In a world where it can be hard to find trust, Tony offers a sense of reliability and dedication that cannot be measured in monetary terms.
I wholeheartedly recommend Tony to anyone in need of legal counsel. His ability to exceed expectations in the legal field, while also bringing a personal, human touch to the experience, is a rare and invaluable trait. I will forever be grateful for his support during such a challenging time, and I am confident anyone who works with him will experience the same outstanding care and professionalism.
Thank you, Tony, for everything.