CrashStory is loading the review analysis, rating patterns, and detailed client feedback for this law firm.
Review Intelligence
The Tarantino Law Firm LLP Buffalo Ny review signals at a glance
CrashStory aggregates public review patterns for The Tarantino Law Firm LLP Buffalo Ny so readers can assess client sentiment, response quality, and the issues that appear most often before moving deeper into the interactive review explorer.
Average Rating
4.2
Total Reviews
25
PI Reviews
19
Text Reviews
25
Ready to talk? Request a free case review from The Tarantino Law Firm LLP Buffalo Ny.
What to check before you hire The Tarantino Law Firm LLP Buffalo Ny
This review summary is rendered directly in the page HTML so readers and crawlers can see the newest review signals, common strengths, and questions to verify even before the interactive explorer loads.
Review Snapshot
4.3
39 public reviews and 25 written reviews.
Recent Activity
Most recent written review from sophia barmore: Mar 3, 2026 (156 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Response Behavior
Replies on 28% of reviews
91% of the visible replies look at least somewhat personalized instead of fully templated.
The Tarantino Law Firm LLP Buffalo Ny client reviews
Recent written reviews appear first. The full interactive review explorer — with sentiment, dimension tags, and complete history — loads below.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
7d0 reviews
-
14d0 reviews
-
30d0 reviews
-
All25 reviews
4.2
Most recent written review from sophia barmore: Mar 3, 2026 (156 days ago)
Written Reviews
25
Average Rating
4.16
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
25
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 25 of 25 written reviews.
1 star
4
2 star
1
3 star
1
4 star
0
5 star
19
Older Written Reviews
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Working with Jacob Piorkowski has given me a great sense of reassurance during a difficult business situation. He takes the time to listen, explain things clearly, and guide you through the proper steps with professionalism and care. If you need an attorney who is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely supportive, Jacob is someone I highly recommend.
I had the privilege of working with Attorney Kevin Wicka during one of the most challenging times in my life. After experiencing a wrongful termination, I was hurt, humiliated, and unsure of how to navigate the legal system. From our very first meeting, it was clear that Kevin is an exceptional attorney with a profound understanding of employment law.
Kevin not only provided top-notch legal expertise but also took the time to walk me through what to expect at each stage of the process. His patience and empathy made a world of difference, helping me shift my focus from dwelling on the past to looking forward to a better future. He shared invaluable insights from his experience with other clients, which helped me adopt a reasonable approach rather than seeking retribution.
Thanks to Kevin's skillful negotiation, we reached a great resolution without the need to appear before a judge. I'm now in a better job and can confidently say that working with Kevin was a pivotal step in turning a negative experience into a positive outcome. I cannot recommend him highly enough—he is truly worth every penny. If you're in need of an attorney who is not only highly competent but also genuinely cares about your well-being, look no further than Kevin Wicka.
Owner response
Thank you so much for your kind words, Brent. We really appreciate you taking the time out to share your positive experience with us. We passed those along to Kevin. Thank you!
I spoke to Jennifer on Tuesday in regards to a probate litigation case in which I'm trying to obtain an attorney for. Even though she's researching my case at this time, I just wanted to let it be known that she did excellent. I've spoken to a few lawyers and I'm not even from the Buffalo area, however she listened to everything I had to say and she really made me feel comfortable. With other firms they always let me talk for a few minutes about what's going on and what I need to obtain an attorney for, but then they hit me with their retainer and I would feel like they really didn't listen to what was going on at all and I would hang up with them a little frustrated. Jennifer was different. She was honest and straightforward with everything, but the biggest difference is she listened to everything I had to say and asked questions along the way that let me know she was listening. She was very understanding and not once did she mention how much it would cost to retain her. In fact she wanted to make sure she was informing me with the correct information about the retainer and that was very big to me. I would definitely like to move forward if possible with her and that's the only thing I was kind of waiting on her to get back to me with today. But I understand attorneys are super busy but I just wanted her to know I appreciate her listening ear and hopefully we can move forward with everything. Thanks again Jennifer. You rock!!
From Jennifer B Monroe County
Owner response
Thank you for letting us know about your great experience with Jennifer. We made sure to pass that along to her and it was greatly appreciated. Thank you again!
Had a horrible experience here. To start, after paying $400 for an hour consultation, the attorney I was meeting with showed up more than 15 minutes late. I understood that they probably had a busy schedule, so I didn't think anything of the tardiness initially. Besides that, I felt satisfied with our conversation and was looking forward to moving on with the process. Over a week went by and I had not heard anything back from the attorney I met with, Kevin Wicka. I reached out to further inquire about the process and was told that according to his notes, he was waiting for me to get back to him. Last time I checked, when you pay a pretty substantial amount for a service, you shouldn't be the one having to initiate conversation, but maybe thats just me. Either way, after going back and forth via email a couple of times to discuss when we would communicate next, Mr. Wicka stopped answering me and I have yet to hear back from him. It has been over a month since we had our initial consultation appointment. Huge waste of time and money while going through an already stressful time.
Owner response
Hello Madison. I did not realize that you were waiting on me. I will reach out to you privately. My apologies. Kevin
I want to share excellent experience I had when I consulted Tarantino Law firm for an urgent legal advice. Before reaching out to them I had reached out to other firms to whom I was referred by a friend but first one was too busy to even reply back regarding appointment and second one wanted a hefty retainer amount to be paid in advance though all I needed was one urgent consult and was willing to pay in advance for the hourly fees . Finally I happened to come across this law firm and read some great reviews about the firm especially Attorney Kevin Wicka so I decided to call them . Emma at reception was very empathetic and gave me an urgent consultation slot right away and also entertained my request to pay online myself via a link emailed to me rather than giving out credit card information over phone. This all happened so fast that I could not believe that I would be finally talking to an Attorney and was quite apprehensive that the appointment might run too quick for me to able discuss to everything thoroughly in one sitting . But when I finally met Attorney Kevin Wicka all my fears were allayed as he made sure that all my queries and counter questions to his advice were answered right away. The legal advice he laid out was well supported by facts and he provided me with both practical and technical perspectives to my issues that helped really clear my vision regarding how to deal with the issue. He explained legal nuances to me in simple terms and made sure I would know what my next course of action should be .And this was what I was hoping to get out from a legal advice. Attorney Wicks was truly point on and I can not thank him enough for helping me out .
Owner response
Thank you so much for that fantastic review! We truly appreciate you sharing your positive experience.
Called and ask for a consultation for wrongful termination they want $400 just to talk "um nevermind click"
Owner response
Hello - Yes, we do charge for our employment law consultations, as they are more complex than other types of cases and take much longer to evaluate. When we do an employment consultation we explore, in detail, the factual background and review documents with the potential client. The fee allows us to provide a premier service. Regrettably, we cannot speak to everyone.<br>
We were lucky enough to get referred to the Tarantino Law Firm by another office in the Rochester area who couldn't take our case due to volume and honestly it was a blessing. We were assigned Kevin Wicka for a wrongful termination consult. Prior to the consult, Kevin thoroughly read through all provided documentation and demonstrated a clear understanding of our timeline, maintained a polite and professional candor, and shared his experience and offered expert legal advice. Kevin was honest with the odds of our outcome, and wouldn't just tell us what we wanted to hear in order to secure a commission. I would recommend Kevin Wicka and Tarantino Law Firm to anybody looking for an employment attorney in the Rochester, NY or Buffalos, Ny areas. You will be in good hands with this firm.
Owner response
Thank you Dave for taking the time to share your experience. We truly appreciate the kind words!
I called a couple months ago and left a message inquiring about what I believed to be discrimination in the workplace. I was called back and told that one of the attorneys could see me but that it would cost $375 for a consultation (regardless of what they claim). Then I was told that it had to be paid in cash, no exceptions. I was also informed that the consultation didn't guarantee that the attorney could form a case around my claim(s) and that he may only offer advice. Well I found that to be a bit odd. So I ended up passing on what would have likely been a waste of my time and money.
P.S. I'm sure they don't have any record of Creature716 being in contact with one of their attorneys...but I'm also sure had I provided my actual name they would have no record of that either. All excuses, no accountability.
Owner response
We are sorry if you had a bad experience. We do not have a record of anyone with your name. We believe that you may either be confusing our office with another or you may have misunderstood what was conveyed - in particular regarding the need for upfront cash. That is absolutely not our policy. In fact, the amount you quoted for the consult is not our rate either.<br><br>As you can see from our reviews we strive to meet our client's expectations. We would welcome an opportunity to speak with you. Please feel free to email our partner, Kevin Wicka, who heads our employment law practice, at kwicka@tarantinolaw.com, and we can set up a call to address your concerns. Thank you.
I am a physician and recently worked with Kevin Wicka concerning a work related business issue. Mr. Wicka is professional, personable, and most importantly highly adept with his knowledge of the law and negotiation skills. He is flexible in that he has the ability and sense of discernment for when to apply full pressure as opposed to taking a more gentle approach. Needless to say, I received excellent advice and in the future, when I need full representation he will be the one that I call.
Owner response
Thank you Marissa for your kind words. We truly appreciate you taking some time to share your experience!
Waste of money and my time. I have a receipt from your poor service.
Owner response
We are sorry if you had a bad experience. We do not have a record of anyone with your name. As you can see from our reviews we strive to meet our client's expectations. We would welcome an opportunity to speak with you. Please feel free to email one of our partners, Kevin Wicka at kwicka@tarantinolaw.com, and we can set up a call to address your concerns. Thank you.
Working with Jacob Piorkowski has given me a great sense of reassurance during a difficult business situation. He takes the time to listen, explain things clearly, and guide you through the proper steps with professionalism and care. If you need an attorney who is knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely supportive, Jacob is someone I highly recommend.
I had the privilege of working with Attorney Kevin Wicka during one of the most challenging times in my life. After experiencing a wrongful termination, I was hurt, humiliated, and unsure of how to navigate the legal system. From our very first meeting, it was clear that Kevin is an exceptional attorney with a profound understanding of employment law.
Kevin not only provided top-notch legal expertise but also took the time to walk me through what to expect at each stage of the process. His patience and empathy made a world of difference, helping me shift my focus from dwelling on the past to looking forward to a better future. He shared invaluable insights from his experience with other clients, which helped me adopt a reasonable approach rather than seeking retribution.
Thanks to Kevin's skillful negotiation, we reached a great resolution without the need to appear before a judge. I'm now in a better job and can confidently say that working with Kevin was a pivotal step in turning a negative experience into a positive outcome. I cannot recommend him highly enough—he is truly worth every penny. If you're in need of an attorney who is not only highly competent but also genuinely cares about your well-being, look no further than Kevin Wicka.