Dawn has been a pleasure to with at William Mattar. We highly recommend useing them.
Analyzing Data...
Analyzing Data...
Request a free case review from William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers in Rochester, New York.
William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers
Rochester Personal Injury Lawyer — 589 Client Reviews Analyzed
4.7(589 reviews)William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers is a Personal Injury law firm in Rochester, NY, located at 16 W Main St #736 and reachable at +1585-444-4444. Clients have rated the firm 4.7 out of 5 across 589 public Google reviews, 10 of which include written feedback. The most recent written review is from Wesley Froebel on May 8, 2026 (125 days ago).
Owner engagement: William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers replies on 6% of visible Google reviews, and roughly 81% of those replies are at least somewhat personalized rather than fully templated — one of the 12 client-experience dimensions CrashStory's review intelligence scores. Use this as a proxy for how responsive the firm is likely to be with you.
What reviewers consistently praise: care for the whole situation, help during a stressful moment, and communication and updates. These themes surfaced across dozens of reviews when CrashStory analyzed sentiment and case-experience dimensions on this firm's Google reviews. Compare these against any other firm you're considering — most attorneys have only two or three themes reviewers consistently return to.
Named attorneys at this firm: William Mattar is the attorney most frequently named by clients in reviews of William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers.
How we compiled this: CrashStory combines public review evidence with directory and firm-provided profile data. We do not endorse any firm. Review intelligence scores are derived from automated sentiment and theme analysis of public reviews — treat them as one signal among many, not a verdict.
589 reviews
Years Experience
Practice Areas
Office Location
Consultation
Each button opens a new tab with a ready-made prompt that references this CrashStory page and the key facts already shown here.
William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers is a personal injury law firm serving clients in Rochester, New York, located at 16 W Main St #736 14614.
Review evidence: Clients have left 589 public Google reviews averaging 4.7 out of 5, 10 of which include written feedback. CrashStory scores 12 client-experience dimensions across this review corpus — compare side-by-side with other Rochester, New York firms before you decide.
Quick signals: attorneys named most often in reviews are William Mattar; the Google Business profile for this firm is verified; 68 photos are public on Google; contact the firm to ask about consultation fees.
Contact William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers at (585) 444-4444 or visit williammattar.com for a free case review.
589 public reviews and 20 written reviews.
Most recent written review from Wesley Froebel: Mar 11, 2026 (183 days ago)
Compare this recency with the other firms you are considering, not just the star rating.
Replies on 100% of recent reviews
The firm responds to reviews; read a few replies below to judge how personal they are.
Most recent written review from Wesley Froebel: Mar 11, 2026 (183 days ago)
CrashStory does not yet have enough structured review evidence on this firm to call out consistent strengths with confidence.
The newest written review in this dataset is from Mar 11, 2026 (183 days ago). Compare that recency with the other firms you are considering.
Dawn has been a pleasure to with at William Mattar. We highly recommend useing them.
This is what the world needs more of
I was so pleased with the communication and support of the William Mattar team after my accident. Their help and guidance was a huge relief in a situation that created a lot of uncertainty for me and my family.
16 W Main St #736, Rochester, NY 14614
Recent crash data for the area around William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers loads when this section comes into view.
Recent written Google reviews from the last 30 days appear first. Older written reviews stay available through pagination and filtering.
Multi-tag filters use OR matching across all assigned classification tags.
Most recent written review from Wesley Froebel: Mar 11, 2026 (183 days ago)
Written Reviews
20
Average Rating
3.70
Reviews (30d)
0
Reviews (90d)
0
Older Archive
20
Assigned Tags (3)
Showing 20 of 20 written reviews.
1 star
5
2 star
2
3 star
0
4 star
0
5 star
13
Reviews older than 30 days are kept available in pages of 12.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Dawn has been a pleasure to with at William Mattar. We highly recommend useing them.
Owner response
Thank you, Wesley! We appreciate it 🤗
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
This is what the world needs more of
Owner response
Thanks so much, Matthew!
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I was so pleased with the communication and support of the William Mattar team after my accident. Their help and guidance was a huge relief in a situation that created a lot of uncertainty for me and my family.
Owner response
Communication and support is always so important, and we work to provide clients with a safe space. On behalf of all of us at William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers, thank you for trusting our team with your case.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Absolutely worthless as attorneys. I hired them in 2013 after a head on collision nearly took my life and now years later the injuries I sustained are massively impacting my quality of life. They did not want to get involved in a trial even though it was completely the other parties fault. They ended up taking the quick buck and settling with the minimum insurance company offer. All these crooks want is to make a fast buck and steal 1/3 of your claim. When you are not in your right state of mind because of trauma, painkillers and misinformation you become easy prey.
Owner response
Anthony, we truly hear the pain in your words and understand how deeply frustrating it is when injuries from a serious accident continue to have a lasting impact on your life. We are always hopeful that healing will leave our clients with the fewest limitations possible, and we recognize how difficult it can be when that is not the outcome.<br><br>We would like to provide some important context regarding your accident from 13 years ago after we successfully secured the full policy limits available, and we continued to look for any additional coverage that could be pursued. Unfortunately, the at-fault party did not have insurance or assets beyond, which significantly limited any further legal options. It was, in fact, your wise decision to have the insurance that you did on your vehicle, as that was ultimately where the financial recovery came from.<br><br>Decisions about whether to pursue a trial are never made lightly. While cases may appear straightforward on the surface, many factors must be considered, including whether a trial would ultimately leave the client in a better financial position after substantial litigation costs are incurred. Trials are expensive and carry significant risk, and if unsuccessful, clients may be responsible for court and expert testimony fees out of pocket. These considerations were discussed at the time, and settlement was pursued to protect your financial outcome.<br><br>The one-third attorney fee is consistent with long-established industry practice and was clearly outlined in the retainer agreement. We realize the trauma that people are left with after an auto accident, and we offer potential clients every opportunity to read the documents thoroughly, and just as importantly, ask as many questions as necessary to understand anything they are not clear on.<br><br>We understand that the legal process often occurs during an incredibly stressful time, when individuals may be coping with trauma, medical treatment, and difficult decisions. When your settlement was finalized, we were hopeful it would allow you to continue your healing and move forward to a more positive next chapter.<br><br>If you would like to discuss your concerns further or review your case with us, we welcome that conversation. Our Attorney Manager, David Rusin, has access to your file and would be happy to speak with you at 585-444-4444.<br>
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
The team is absolutely wonderful to to work with
Owner response
Thank you, Marissa! Our team said the same thing about you! 🙂
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Good injury lawyer there help is 100% spot on i get call back and update about my case 2 thumbs up 👍 👌 😀
Owner response
Thank you for calling on our team to help you.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I would honestly choose any other lawyer if I could pick again. I got into a car accident almost a year and a half and they have been dragging their feet to get any kind of settlement or closure for me for the last year. anytime I call they make me feel like an inconvenient or like I'm bugging them when I'm trying to get updates. No communication and they truly don't care unless you're worth millions of dollars.
Owner response
We understand how frustrating it can feel when a case takes longer than expected to resolve. Every matter moves at its own pace depending on several factors, including the parties involved, and the requirements of the agencies handling various parts of the process. There are times of heavy activity and times when progress slows, but we strive to maintain communication throughout.<br><br>Policy limits do not influence the level of attention or respect we display—we want every client to feel supported and informed. Even though your attorney has discussed your concerns, we invite you to please contact our Attorney Manager, David Rusin, at 585-444-4444 with any additional questions you may have as we continue working toward a positive resolution on your case.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
Just want closure on our case. No call backs I give up after awhile. The woman I talked to acted like it was a burden that I called. She never explained the status of our case in terms I could understand. What a wasted call! I realize they are very busy , I'm hoping that this ends soon . I need closure in my life. Thank. You
Owner response
Thank you for sharing your concerns, Debbie. We’re very sorry to hear you’ve felt unheard during such an important time — you deserve clear communication and support. We want to investigate this right away, but we’re unable to identify your file with the information in this review. We kindly ask you call our Attorney Manager, David Rusin, at 585-444-4444 so we can locate your case, understand what happened, and work toward the closure you’re looking for. We truly value our clients, and we want to make this right for you.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
I would not recommend this law firm. They don’t return phone calls and when they do, it’s like 7to 8 days later.
Owner response
Danielle, thank you for reaching out. After reviewing our records, it appears we spoke with you on the day of your accident, sent several emails with preliminary information, and worked to start your case. The following day, you let us know you had chosen alternate representation, and we closed your file at your request with no additional interaction. <br><br>If there’s been any misunderstanding or if you’d like to talk further, we’d be happy to reconnect and help in any way we can. Please call our Attorney Manager, David Rusin who will be happy to speak with you. 585-444-4444.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
The lawyers are very helpful and efficient. When my husband passed away they were very compassionate. I definitely would recommend them to my friends.
Owner response
Thank you, Karen. We appreciate you and your family trusting us to help, and we wish you the very best.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
We had the most amazing lawyers through William Mattar they explained everything that was going on with the case and kept us well informed and every step they were making
Owner response
Thank you, Melanie. Your team at William Mattar Rochester Accident Lawyers would like to thank you for letting us help you with your case.
Case Type Unspecified
Unknown
These lawyers are the best lawyers out there Every time they called me to explain everything that was going on . I would tell all my friends to give this firm call
Owner response
Thank you for trusting our team to help. We wish you the very best moving forward.
5 other offices for this firm
William Mattar Accident Lawyers
The Mattar Firm
William Mattar Albany Accident Lawyers
William Mattar Syracuse Accident Lawyers
William Mattar Buffalo Accident Lawyers
Other personal injury lawyers near this office
Browse all personal injury lawyers serving Rochester, New York.
View All Rochester LawyersCompare nearby firms, browse city lawyer directories, and read case-type guides before you decide who to contact.
0 this week, 0 this month
Last review 150d ago
improving