Skip to main content
Live
Loading incidents...
The Honest Guide

The Honest Guide to Colorado Car Accident Claims

Everything that's going to happen — before it happens.

From crash to check. No spin. No sales pitch. ~20 min read.

Transparency note: timeline, fee, and payout figures on this page are planning estimates, not guarantees. Tool outputs are illustrative. Legal outcomes depend on injury facts, insurance coverage, contract terms, and current law.

The Full Timeline

Most Colorado car accident claims follow a 12-24 month arc. Here is every phase, mapped to a timeline so you know exactly where you are and what comes next.

The Full Timeline: Crash to Check

Click any phase to jump to its details. Most cases follow this 8–24 month arc.

Phase by Phase: What Actually Happens

Each card below covers one phase of your case. Expand any phase to see exactly what happens, what your lawyer is doing, and what you should be doing.

1

The First 48 Hours

Signing up & evidence preservation

Months 00Expect 3-5 contacts in the first 48 hours: intake call, retainer signing, initial strategy call, and follow-ups about medical treatment and evidence. This is the highest-communication phase of your entire case.Feeling: Shock, adrenaline, confusion, relief at having someone in your corner.

Honest Truth

This is the only phase where your lawyer will seem aggressive and highly responsive - enjoy it. The pace slows dramatically after this because the next phase is driven by your medical treatment timeline, not your attorney's calendar.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • You meet with an attorney for a free consultation - usually the same day or next day.
  • If there is a fit you sign a contingency-fee retainer agreement (typically 33.33% pre-litigation).
  • The attorney sends a letter of representation to the at-fault driver's insurance company.
  • Your lawyer's office orders the official police report and begins a spoliation letter to preserve dash-cam, surveillance, and black-box data.
  • If injuries are visible, the firm may send an investigator or photographer to the scene.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Reviews police report and photographs for initial liability assessment.
  • Opens an insurance claim on your behalf and confirms policy limits.
  • Sends preservation-of-evidence letters to all relevant parties.
  • Coordinates with your health insurance or med-pay coverage to ensure treatment is covered.
  • Sets up your case file - intake form, medical-release authorizations, and contact protocol.

What You Should Do

  • Seek medical attention immediately, even if you feel fine - adrenaline masks pain.
  • Photograph everything: your vehicle damage, the scene, your visible injuries, and the other driver's information.
  • Do not give a recorded statement to the other driver's insurance company.
  • Follow up with your primary care doctor or an urgent care within 72 hours.
  • Start a simple pain journal - date, pain level (1-10), what you cannot do.
2

The Treatment Phase

The "dead zone" - active healing, minimal lawyer contact

Months 17Expect around 1-2 contacts per month, often from a paralegal or case manager rather than the attorney. This can be normal during treatment, especially in firms handling many active files at once.Feeling: Frustration, anxiety, feeling forgotten, questioning whether you made the right choice hiring this lawyer.

Honest Truth

Your lawyer hasn't forgotten you. They're waiting because settling before you finish treatment can leave money on the table. Insurance companies know that injured people get desperate - the longer treatment takes, the more pressure you feel to settle cheap. Your lawyer's silence can be strategy, not neglect. That said, you absolutely deserve a status call if you ask for one.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • You attend all prescribed medical appointments - physical therapy, orthopedic follow-ups, imaging, specialist referrals.
  • Your medical bills accumulate and your health insurer (or med-pay) processes claims.
  • The at-fault insurer's adjuster may call you directly - do not engage without your lawyer.
  • Months pass with little apparent progress on the legal side.
  • This is the phase where most clients start to feel forgotten.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Periodically requests updated medical records and bills from your providers.
  • Monitors your treatment progress without interfering in medical decisions.
  • Handles any communication from the at-fault insurer so you don't have to.
  • May send a status letter to the insurance company to keep the claim active.
  • Waits — intentionally — because settling before treatment ends often leaves money on the table.

What You Should Do

  • Go to every single appointment. Gaps in treatment are the number-one thing insurance companies use to devalue claims.
  • Keep your pain journal updated - even brief entries like "back pain 6/10, couldn't pick up my kid" matter enormously.
  • Save every receipt: co-pays, prescriptions, parking at medical offices, mileage to appointments.
  • If you miss work, get written documentation from your employer.
  • Call your lawyer's office for a status update if you haven't heard anything in 6 weeks. You have the right to know what's happening.
3

Maximum Medical Improvement (MMI)

Your doctor says you've plateaued - the case wakes up

Months 69Expect 4-6 contacts this month. Your lawyer or paralegal will call about records, request your input on the impact statement, and begin discussing valuation range. This is the phase where your case transitions from passive to active.Feeling: Cautious hope mixed with anxiety about what the case is actually worth.

Honest Truth

MMI doesn't mean you're healed. It means your condition has stabilized enough for the lawyer to calculate what your case is worth. Some people never fully recover - that's actually relevant to valuation. If you have permanent limitations, that increases your damages. Don't minimize your symptoms to your doctor.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • Your treating physician determines you have reached MMI - the point where your condition has stabilized or further improvement is unlikely.
  • If you have permanent impairment, your doctor may assign an impairment rating (this significantly increases case value).
  • Your lawyer's office requests final medical records, billing summaries, and any outstanding imaging or specialist reports.
  • Communication picks up noticeably - the legal work is about to begin in earnest.
  • You may be asked to complete a detailed questionnaire about how the accident changed your daily life.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Orders complete medical records from every provider you visited.
  • Requests itemized billing statements and confirms amounts with your health insurer.
  • Begins calculating economic damages: medical bills, lost wages, future care estimates.
  • Assesses non-economic damages: pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment, emotional distress.
  • Starts drafting the framework for the demand letter.

What You Should Do

  • Make sure your doctor clearly documents your current condition and any ongoing limitations.
  • Compile a list of everything you can no longer do or that has become significantly harder since the accident.
  • Gather final wage-loss documentation from your employer if applicable.
  • Respond promptly to your lawyer's requests for information - delays here delay your settlement.
  • Ask your lawyer to walk you through the valuation approach they're planning.
4

The Demand Letter

Building the single most important document in your case

Months 812Expect 3-5 contacts during demand preparation, then a period of quiet (2-4 weeks) while the insurer reviews. Your lawyer should notify you when the demand goes out and when a response is received.Feeling: Anticipation, nervousness about the number, impatience during the insurer's review period.

Honest Truth

A good demand letter takes weeks to prepare. It is the single most important document in your case. Rushing it costs you money. Every unsupported claim weakens the package. Every missing medical record gives the insurer an excuse to offer less. This is where your lawyer earns the fee - or doesn't.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • Your attorney compiles a comprehensive demand package: medical records chronology, billing summary, wage documentation, impact narrative, liability analysis, and a specific dollar demand.
  • The demand letter is reviewed, revised, and finalized - this process alone can take 2-4 weeks for a complex case.
  • The package is sent to the at-fault driver's insurance company with a response deadline (usually 30 days).
  • The insurer assigns a claims adjuster (or re-assigns to a senior adjuster) to evaluate the demand.
  • You wait again - but this time with a clear endpoint.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Writes a detailed narrative connecting the accident to every injury, treatment, and life impact.
  • Organizes medical records chronologically and highlights key findings.
  • Calculates total economic damages with supporting documentation.
  • Argues for appropriate non-economic (pain and suffering) damages with case-law support.
  • Sets a strategic demand amount - high enough to leave negotiation room, credible enough to be taken seriously.

What You Should Do

  • Review the demand letter draft if your lawyer shares it - you know your story best.
  • Provide any missing documentation promptly.
  • Understand that the demand amount is a starting position, not the expected outcome.
  • Be patient during the insurer's review period - they are allowed their response time.
  • Ask your lawyer what range of outcomes they consider realistic so you can set informed expectations.
5

Negotiation

Offers, counteroffers, and the patience game

Months 1016Variable - expect 3-6 contacts per month during active negotiation. There may be gaps of 1-2 weeks between rounds as the adjuster reviews counteroffers internally. Your lawyer should update you after every round.Feeling: Impatience, second-guessing, frustration with low offers, temptation to just take whatever is on the table.

Honest Truth

The insurance company has every incentive to wait you out. They know your bills are piling up. They know you're tired of the process. Your lawyer's job is to make waiting more expensive for them than paying you. The first offer is a test - it tells the insurer whether you'll fold under pressure or hold firm. If your lawyer recommends rejecting it, there's usually a reason.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • The insurance company responds to the demand — often with a low first offer.
  • Your attorney counters with a reasoned response addressing each of the insurer's objections.
  • Multiple rounds of offers and counteroffers follow, typically 2-5 rounds over several weeks.
  • The adjuster may request additional documentation, an independent medical exam (IME), or recorded statements.
  • If negotiations stall, your attorney discusses the option of filing a lawsuit to increase pressure.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Evaluates the insurer's first offer against the case value range.
  • Drafts counteroffers with specific evidence addressing each deduction the insurer made.
  • Negotiates medical lien reductions with your health insurer or providers to increase your net recovery.
  • Advises you on whether to accept, counter, or escalate to litigation.
  • Documents every offer and counteroffer in writing.

What You Should Do

  • Do not accept or reject any offer without discussing it with your attorney.
  • Understand the difference between gross settlement and net-to-you after fees, costs, and liens.
  • Ask your lawyer to explain why they recommend accepting or rejecting each offer.
  • Be honest about your financial pressure - your lawyer needs to know if you're running out of runway.
  • Remember that the first offer is often not the best offer. Insurance adjusters are trained to start conservatively.
6

Litigation (If Needed)

Filing suit is a tactic, not necessarily a trial

Months 1224Expect 2-4 contacts per month during discovery, increasing to weekly as mediation or trial approaches. Deposition preparation will require 1-2 dedicated sessions with your attorney.Feeling: Anxiety about court, fear of depositions, frustration at more delays, but also empowerment that you're fighting back.

Honest Truth

Filing a lawsuit doesn't mean you're going to trial. It means the insurance company's first strategy - waiting and lowballing - stopped working. Many cases still settle before trial, including at or after mediation. The lawsuit is leverage. Your attorney files it because the insurer was not negotiating in good faith, and a court deadline forces movement. A fee increase to 40% is common and reflects the significantly increased work.

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • Your attorney files a civil complaint in Colorado district court. The contingency fee typically increases to 40% once suit is filed.
  • The defendant (and their insurer) must file an Answer within 21 days.
  • Discovery begins: written interrogatories, document requests, and depositions of both parties and witnesses.
  • The court may schedule a mandatory mediation session - a structured settlement conference with a neutral mediator.
  • A large majority of filed personal injury cases settle before reaching trial.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Prepares and files the complaint, serves the defendant, and manages all court deadlines.
  • Conducts discovery - deposing the other driver, reviewing insurance files, and gathering expert opinions.
  • Retains expert witnesses if needed: accident reconstructionists, medical experts, economists.
  • Prepares for and attends mediation - the most common settlement point for litigated cases.
  • Continues negotiation even while preparing for trial.

What You Should Do

  • Prepare for your deposition - your lawyer will coach you, but you need to commit time to preparation.
  • Be truthful in all discovery responses. Inconsistencies destroy credibility.
  • Continue any prescribed medical treatment - stopping treatment during litigation looks like you've recovered.
  • Understand that litigation can add 6-12 months and may improve negotiation leverage, but outcomes are not guaranteed.
  • Ask your lawyer about the realistic timeline and costs of continuing to trial versus settling now.
7

Settlement & Payout

Where the money actually goes

Months 1424Expect 3-5 contacts during the disbursement process. Your lawyer should walk you through the settlement statement in detail and be available for questions about deductions.Feeling: Relief mixed with sticker shock at deductions, closure, sometimes disappointment that the net is less than expected.

Honest Truth

The gross settlement number is not your number. After attorney fees (often 33-40%), case costs, medical liens, and health insurance subrogation, your check can be much lower than the headline figure. A $100,000 settlement might land closer to $50,000 in some cases, but every file is different. The honest question is not "why is my check smaller?" but "did I understand the breakdown before agreeing?"

See what happens in this phase

What Happens

  • Both parties agree on a settlement amount and sign a release.
  • The insurance company issues a settlement check (often within a few weeks of signed release).
  • Your attorney deposits the check in a trust account and begins the disbursement process.
  • Medical liens, subrogation claims, case costs, and attorney fees are deducted.
  • You receive your net check - often several weeks after the settlement agreement.

What Your Lawyer Does

  • Negotiates medical liens and subrogation claims to maximize your net recovery.
  • Prepares a detailed settlement statement showing every deduction line by line.
  • Ensures all providers and lien holders sign off before distributing funds.
  • Explains the final numbers to you in a closing meeting or call.
  • Closes your file and provides you with copies of all key documents.

What You Should Do

  • Review the settlement statement carefully - every line item should be explained.
  • Ask your lawyer how lien amounts were negotiated and whether any reductions were achieved.
  • Understand that the gross settlement number is not your number.
  • Keep copies of your settlement agreement and disbursement statement for tax records.
  • Consult a tax professional about whether any portion of your settlement may be taxable.

How Often You'll Actually Hear From Your Lawyer

The number-one complaint in personal injury cases is lack of communication. This calendar shows realistic expectations month by month so you can tell the difference between normal silence and actual neglect.

How Often You'll Hear From Your Lawyer

Expected contacts per month across a typical case. The dip in months 2–7 is the “Dead Zone” — normal but frustrating.

06121824

The “Dead Zone” (Months 2–7)

This is normal. Your lawyer is waiting for medical treatment to finish before they can calculate what your case is worth. Calling every week won't speed it up — but requesting a written monthly status email is completely reasonable.

The Money Truth: What You Actually Take Home

The gross settlement number is not your number. Here is where every dollar goes, with a side-by-side comparison of hiring a lawyer versus going alone.

Lawyer vs. No Lawyer: The Full Comparison

CategoryWith a LawyerWithout a Lawyer
Typical settlement leverageCan improve negotiation leverage in moderate to complex injury claimsMay be sufficient for some minor claims with clear liability and low damages
Attorney fee cost33-40% of recovery (contingency - you pay nothing upfront)$0
Net to you after feesCan still be higher after fees in many moderate/complex casesNo fee deduction, but gross recovery may be lower depending on case complexity
Case costs (filing, records, experts)$2,000-$15,000 (advanced by firm, deducted from settlement)$500-$3,000 (you pay out of pocket, often skip key steps)
Medical lien negotiationAttorney can often seek reductions on some liens/reimbursement claimsLien negotiation is still possible but often harder without legal support
Time to resolveOften longer due to documentation, negotiation, and possible litigationCan resolve faster in straightforward claims, but recovery may be lower in complex injuries
Adjuster pressure tacticsAttorney handles most communication once represented, reducing direct adjuster pressureYou face trained negotiators alone - they do this every day, you don't
Documentation qualityProfessional demand package with medical chronology and legal argumentsSelf-represented packages vary widely and may miss evidence needed to support value
Statute of limitations protectionAttorney tracks all deadlines - malpractice insurance backstops errorsFor Colorado motor-vehicle injury claims, missing the 3-year filing deadline generally bars recovery
Contingency riskAttorney fees are usually tied to recovery; review contract terms for advanced costs if there is no recoveryNo fee risk, but you also have no expert in your corner

Where a $100K Settlement Actually Goes

Where Your Settlement Money Goes

Enter a gross settlement amount to see how much you'd actually take home.

$
Gross Settlement
$100,000
Attorney Fee (33%)
-$33,000
Case Costs
-$5,000
Medical Liens
-$8,000
Health Insurance Subrogation
-$4,000
Net to You
$50,000
Gross Settlement
$100,000
Net to You
$50,000
(50% of gross)

Net Recovery: With vs. Without Representation

Illustrative example only. Actual gross and net outcomes vary by injuries, coverage, liability, medical repayments, and case strategy.

With a Lawyer

Gross Settlement
$85,000
Attorney Fee (33%)
-$28,050
Case Costs
-$4,500
Medical Liens (negotiated)
-$6,000
Net to You
$46,450

Without a Lawyer

Gross Settlement
$25,000
Attorney Fee
$0
Case Costs
$0
Medical Liens (full price)
-$8,000
Net to You
$17,000

In this example, even after paying the 33% fee, the represented client nets $29,450 more than the unrepresented client.

Insurance Adjuster Reality

Insurance adjusters are not your advocate. They are trained professionals with performance metrics tied to paying you as little as possible. Here is what the industry looks like from the inside.

What Your Adjuster's Day Looks Like

Insurance adjusters are not evil. They are employees with quotas, managers, and performance reviews. Understanding their reality helps you navigate the process without taking delays personally.

Varies
Active claims per adjuster
Often high-volume workflows
Limited
Time available per claim
Depends on claim complexity and staffing
Common
Internal settlement targets
Carrier and role dependent
Often present
Incentive to close files
Speed and consistency are measured
Standard
Negotiation training
Process-driven claim handling

What This Means for You

Your claim is one of many on someone's desk. The adjuster's job is to close files efficiently and within budget. A quick, low offer is often a business strategy, not a personal judgment. Legal representation can change the negotiation dynamic, but outcomes still depend on facts, coverage, and documentation.

The Emotional Rollercoaster

Nobody warns you about the emotional toll of a car accident case. This map charts what most people feel at each stage so you know you are not alone and you are not losing your mind.

The Emotional Rollercoaster Nobody Warns You About

These emotional phases are normal. Knowing they're coming makes them easier to manage.

Month 0
Shock & Relief9/10

The accident just happened. Adrenaline is high. You're scared but also relieved to have a lawyer handling things. Everything feels urgent.

Month 1
Determination7/10

You're going to appointments, following the plan, feeling proactive. The pain is real but you're doing something about it.

Month 3
Frustration6/10

Treatment is ongoing but nothing seems to be happening with your case. You haven't heard from your lawyer in weeks. You start wondering if this is normal.

Month 5
Anxiety & Doubt8/10

Bills are piling up. You're still in pain. Your lawyer's office sends you to voicemail. You Google "is my lawyer doing anything" at 2 AM. This is the emotional low point for most people.

Month 7
Weary Patience5/10

You've accepted the timeline but you're tired. Treatment is winding down. You just want this to be over.

Month 9
Cautious Hope6/10

MMI is reached, your lawyer is calling again, the demand letter is being prepared. It feels like progress for the first time in months.

Month 11
Anticipation7/10

The demand is out. You know a number is coming back. You oscillate between optimism and dread.

Month 13
Impatience & Anger8/10

The first offer was insulting. The back-and-forth feels pointless. You want to yell at someone. Your lawyer says "trust the process." You hate that phrase.

Month 16
Resolve or Exhaustion7/10

If litigation was filed, you feel a mix of empowerment and fear. If negotiation continues, you're running on fumes. Either way, you're closer to the end than the beginning.

Month 19
Guarded Optimism6/10

Mediation or final negotiations are happening. Real numbers are on the table. You allow yourself to think about what you'll do with the money.

Month 22
Relief & Sticker Shock8/10

The case settled. You're done - but the settlement statement shows deductions you expected intellectually but still weren't emotionally ready for. The net check is smaller than the headline number.

Month 24
Closure4/10

The check cleared. The case is closed. You feel lighter, but also strange - like finishing a marathon. Some people feel grateful, some feel cheated, most feel both.

This is not weakness. Every person going through a car accident claim experiences these emotions. The difference is that now you know they're coming, so they won't blindside you.

Things Nobody Tells You

The uncomfortable truths that most law firm websites leave out. Read these before you sign anything.

Your Lawyer Has Other Active Cases

You are not their only client. Many personal injury attorneys manage dozens of active matters at once. Your case gets more attention when a milestone is pending and less during routine waiting periods. That can be normal, but you should still receive updates when you ask.

The First Offer Is a Test

Insurance adjusters are trained negotiators and first offers are often conservative. If you accept immediately, you may leave value on the table. Ask for a written breakdown and compare it against your documented damages before deciding.

Your Medical Records ARE the Case

Your testimony matters, but your medical records are what drive settlement value. Consistent treatment, clear documentation of symptoms, and objective findings (MRIs, X-rays, nerve studies) are worth more than anything you say. Gaps in treatment - even a 3-week break - give the insurer ammunition to argue you weren't really hurt.

Most Cases Settle at Mediation, Not Trial

Despite what TV shows suggest, only a small share of personal injury cases go to trial. Many resolve during negotiation or mediation. If your lawyer recommends mediation, that is usually a normal strategy, not a sign of weakness.

"Pain and Suffering" Is Not a Made-Up Number

Non-economic damages are calculated using real frameworks: severity multipliers, per-diem rates, comparable jury verdicts, and bilateral negotiation history. Adjusters use software like Colossus or Claims IQ to generate ranges. Your lawyer counters with their own analysis. The final number is a negotiated middle ground, not a guess.

Your Health Insurance Will Want Their Money Back

If your health insurer paid for accident-related treatment, reimbursement (subrogation) may apply. This surprises most people. In some cases, your attorney can negotiate reductions, but results vary by plan type and governing law.

Posting on Social Media Can Tank Your Case

Insurance defense teams may monitor claimants' social media. A photo of you at a concert, hiking, or even smiling at a birthday party can be used to argue you're not as injured as you claim. Set everything to private and post cautiously about physical activities until your case is closed.

The "3x Medical Bills" Formula Is a Myth

You may have heard that settlements are "3 times medical bills." Treat that as an outdated rule of thumb, not a reliable formula. Case value depends on injury type, treatment duration, liability strength, jurisdiction, and available coverage. A $30,000 medical bill does not automatically mean a $90,000 settlement.

Pre-Existing Conditions Don't Kill Your Case

Colorado follows the "eggshell plaintiff" doctrine - the defendant takes you as they find you. If you had a bad back before the accident and the crash made it worse, you're entitled to compensation for the aggravation. The insurer will try to blame everything on your pre-existing condition. Your lawyer's job is to prove what changed.

You Can Fire Your Lawyer

You have the right to terminate your attorney at any time. You may owe them for costs advanced and a reasonable fee for work performed, but you are not trapped. If communication has completely broken down, if your lawyer can't explain their strategy, or if you've lost trust - switching is an option. Get a consultation with a new attorney before making the move.

One-Page Cheat Sheet

Timeline Reality

  • Many claims resolve in roughly 8-18 months; complex litigation can take longer.
  • Treatment-heavy months can feel quiet while records and recovery progress.
  • Only a small share of cases reach trial; filing suit can be leverage in negotiation.

Money Reality

  • Net can be materially lower than gross after fees, costs, and medical repayment obligations.
  • Contingency fees often fall in roughly the 30-40% range, with contract-specific terms.
  • Representation can improve leverage in many cases, but outcomes vary.

Communication Reality

  • Expect higher contact early, then periodic updates during treatment-heavy phases.
  • A practical benchmark is 1-3 business days for routine replies; escalate if >2 weeks with no response.
  • Request written status updates so expectations stay clear.

Insurance Reality

  • Adjusters often handle high caseloads and process-driven metrics.
  • The first offer is often conservative, not the final valuation.
  • Do not sign a release before understanding treatment status and future-care risk.

Your Rights

  • You can fire your lawyer and hire a new one at any time.
  • You are never obligated to accept a settlement offer.
  • You can request an itemized breakdown of any offer.
  • Colorado motor-vehicle injury claims are generally subject to a 3-year limit; other claim types can differ.